Immigration and regional wage rates

by on July 19, 2006 at 1:36 am in History | Permalink

I was reading the interesting-but-not-nearly-as-good-as-it could-have-been Blessed Among Nations: How the World Made America, by Eric Rauchway.  The main argument concerns how modern-day America is rooted in choices from the early twentieth century.  I came across the following passage:

The great push of people west across the oceans and west again across the continent passed the South by.  Its people lived in an eddy of the global flow that entered the country at New York (where almost a quarter of the new immigrants stayed) and sluiced along the rail lines to California.  Indeed, in the wash of this passing current, the South was losing its own labor force, more swiftly each year, as black workers left their homes looking for the better chances they had heard about in the North and West.  Of those who left the South, the largest part (about 40 percent) went to the industrial states of New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Illinois…

OK, this is not a controlled experiment.  But we have one part of the country — the North — taking in many immigrants.  The South is losing a great deal of its unskilled, low-education labor at the same time, and it is losing that labor to the North.  Think of that as additional immigration into the North and of course away from the South.

I am far away from home and have no access to data.  Does anyone know?  If we look at the wages of native white Americans — in the South and in the North — over this same period of time, where do people fare better?

Please leave your knowledge in the comments.

ElamBend July 19, 2006 at 7:33 am

Given that in the early part of the last century textile and other mills started heading to the south to take advantage of lower wages and less union activity, I would postulate that workers traveling north and west initially pushed wages down due to over-supply of labor, however, this was followed by labor organization which pushed wages up. Furthermore, the large labor pool allowed northern cities to undergo huge expansion and accomplish big constructive feats. I think specifically of chicago, which both reconstructed itself and built the 1892 Worlds Fair in short order.
In the south the lack of development and jobs had to have had downward pressure on unskilled labor (while at the same time upward pressure on skilled labor). A study of the economic redevelopement of the South probably would provide a good example of what is going on in northern Mexico right now.

Steve Sailer July 19, 2006 at 10:35 am

This reminds me of David Card’s study of how the Mariel boatlift to Miami in 1980 didn’t depress wages relative to four countrol cities. Of course, it’s only persuasive if Miami’s experience from 1980 to 1985 was ceteris paribus relative to other American cities at the same time. But I seem to recall from movies like “Scarface” and TV shows like that a unique event was pumping billions into the local Miami economy in the early 1980s. Can you recall what that was?

Johnny Debacle July 19, 2006 at 11:53 am

“Interestingly, some of the destinations of those migrants, most notably Detroit, then collapsed due in part to problem assimilating those internal migrants from the South.”

Yeah Detroit collapsed…100 years later.

spencer July 19, 2006 at 5:20 pm

In the historic stats Table f287
you find percapita regional income data.
It is not broken down by race but the
South AtlanticA) and East South Central(ESC)
are clearly the poorest areas of the country.

the ratio of percapita income to the US =100

…….SA….ESC

1840…70…..73
1880…45…..51
1900…45…..49
1920…59…..52
1940…69…..56
1960…77…..67
1970…86…..74

this data says the south was killed by the civil war and did not really start recovering until after 1900.

beowulf July 19, 2006 at 8:21 pm

The bigger issue is why the migration from South to North occurred.

There were two things, a push and a pull. The push was that improving agriculture technology (mechanization and better herbicdes) made field hands redundant (Nicholas Lemann’s wonderful book The Promised Land goes into this in some detail). Since the New Deal agriculture support programs helped the farmer and not the farm hand, the only choice was to move to the cities to find work. The racist white power structure in South no doubt liked seeing their unwanted population (i.e. African-American) move far away.

The pull was the demand for labor in Northern factories, World War II played a big role (taking 12 million men out of the civilian job sector even as the GDP doubles— now that’s a labor shortage!), but remember also that from the mid 1920′s to the mid 1960′s, our immigration laws were very strict. Factory owners may have preferred, as they had always done, to hire immmigrants instead of African-Americans, but because of the immigration code and later, the War, this wasn’t an option.

Hans Gruber July 20, 2006 at 5:16 pm

Tyler can’t be serious. Is he really suggesting that immigrants increased wages? This
confuses cause and effect. Immigrants went to those places because they were booming and wages were high.
They did NOT cause the higher wages or the better living standards.

Quetzacoatl November 8, 2006 at 5:53 pm

annonces dominatrice transsexuelle travesti location a trans en provence annuaire escorte trans escorte girls trans et massage paris escorte trans france contribution photo transsexuel hard transsexuel mise a jour codec trans continent annonce rencontre trav trans shemale marseille black trans escorte girl transsexuel paris escorte transsexuelle toulouse escorte montreal transsexuelle escorte trans in cote azur massage transsexuel escorte transsexuelle independente paris asian trans chat transsexuelle gratuit escorte girl transsexuel agence toulouse galerie trans film transsexuel gratuit telechargable annuaire transsexuel gratuit boutique trans angel collection paris mairie de trans en provence hormone transsexuelle clip video transsexuel chirurgie transformation transsexuel video cecile and petite and trans belle photo transsexuelle annonces and transsexuelle chat gratuit transsexuelle photo gratuit transsexuelle et travesti chat transsexuelle sur bordeaux transsexuelle cote azur chat avec des transsexuelle annonces transsexuelle martigues escorte transsexuelle toulouse galerie photo gratuite shemale transsexuelle meilleur site transsexuelle gratuit annonces transsexuelle sur paris transsexuelle escorte annonces petite annonces transsexuelle transsexuelle x porno rencontre transsexuelle paris photo porno transsexuelle video x transsexuelle black contact transsexuelle france galerie dephotos transsexuelle transsexuelle montreal escorte photo x transsexuelle rencontre transsexuelle lyon video black transsexuelle tres belle queue transsexuelle annuaire escorte transsexuelle massage anal paris transsexuelle plus belle bite transsexuelle plus belle transsexuelle paris transsexuelle rose bo film stay with produit occasion critique film fantastique chris tucker film dvd sortie 01 1999 film et video critique and film film x regarder gratuitement sans telecharger film video francais gratuit telecharger film sortie 2004 bo du film si seulement sortie film harry potter et homme sang mele regarder un film gratuitement film erotique selection critique film et photo porno telecharger film harry potter et prisonnier azkaban video telecharger film liste shindler gratuit video film lapidation film indien amerique sortie de film aujourd hui dernier film sortie en salle sortie film harry potter et coupe feu film photo liste de film lesbien tournage film guerre monde guerre des monde origintype film casting film x paris telechargement film long gratuit transsexuel origintype film ancien film fantastique telechargement gratuit de film et musique territoire mort origintype film telechargement de film de cinema gratuit download and film and divx and telecharger and divx gratuit extrait de film sexy film alexandre grand telecharger divx xx origintype film photo film fantastique nouveau film porno arabe film visionner non telecharger enfant alexandre le grand le film film porno sexy film gratuit sans telechargement film erotique regardes nikki anderson telecharger film telechargement film erotique musique film x files film cul telecharger film pornographique moins cher monde fred romano telechargement film dvd telechargement de film sur internet travelo film amateur pornographique film xxx film et jaquette madagascar le film clip video film x affiche de film gratuite film pirate telechargement gratuit toutes affiche film musique du film ghost film erotique produit celine martin jaquette and film demo film x film hard x jaquette gratuit film telecharger film bittorent affiche de film gladiator morceau film cul gratuit jacquette de dvd pour film film porno americain film au cinema pour enfant extrait gratuit de film porno dorothee film pornographique festival du film britannique dinard festival film court villeurbanne film sortie au cinema video cinema film noir et blanc rene chateau film hard avec rocco siffredi film sex porno multivision tv festival film d aventure louer film dvd sexe xxx extrait film voir des film de cul gratuit film and xxx film arab xxx extrait film x gratis film cul bite chatte gratuit extrait film sexy amateur film amateur porno gratuit x and gratuit and film and x and gratuit and extrait and sexe film adulte hit parade extrait telecharge film porno film x complet a telecharger gratuitement hentai film x telecharger location film adulte film and x and a and telecharger bande and originale and de and film naturisme film x amateur film video adulte film x entier telecharger film xxl gratuit sexe film x telecharger gratuite telecharge film brice nice jacquette film verso jeune fille cochon msn photo jeune salope gratuite jeune femme cochon jeune petite salope jeune teen jeune afrique l intelligent.fr jeune fille au pair bretagne gibert jeune versailles enterrement vie jeune fille nord jeune salope xxx jeune et jolie femme google intelligent jeune afrique jeune societe generale enterrement vie jeune fille macon photo jeune femme foyer jeune travailleur saint germain laye enterrement vie jeune fille photo amateur enterrement vie jeune fille cadeaux jeune femme nu gratuit photo jeune et jolie foyer jeune travailleur hauts de seine jeune fille cochon 14 ans tarif assurance jeune conducteur rencontre jeune maman photo x de jeune fille photo sex ultra jeune gratuite jeune femme nu site educatrice de jeune enfant formation photo and and jeune and suceuse jeune sexe gratuit date concours educatrice jeune enfant jeune amatrice exhibitionnisye galerie photo jeune fille photo gratuite de jeune chatte jeune sexe partouze photo de jeune femme nu gratuit jeune mec gratuit video gratuit prison jeune diplome fort potentiel photo amateur jeune fille vicieuse sex jeune etudiante photo jeune etudiante coquin mec jeune ecole d educatrice de jeune enfant en guadeloupe jeune femme amateur de sexe vieille et jeune sex jeune minet bandants jeune sapeur pompier de versailles taux du livret jeune jeune conducteur vitesse limitation de vitesse pour jeune conducteur asiatique jeune salope exces de vitesse par jeune conducteur tchatche gratuit entre jeune jeune teen mod le permis conduire jeune conducteur blog fnj jeune niques france degage jeune garcon homosexuel nu gratuit jeune baisent vieille photo gratuite jeune nudiste gratuit site tchatche jeune photo x jeune fille telecharge infraction jeune conducteur photo porno de jeune photo jeune garcon nu programme jeune aller travailler france carte frequence jeune air france photo fille jeune 18 photo vieille cherche jeune homme sncf carte jeune femme mure mini jupe photo gratuite rencontre femme mure nice webcam amatrice mure video sexe mure nu femme mure photo gratuit sexe et sodomie amatrice mure femme femme mure gratuit sexe annonce amatrice mure film porno femme mure salope mure gratuite video de femme mure nu sexe porno femme mure mature sex femme mure porno annonce femme mure rencontre jeune homme huge and hooters and mature and movie sexe gratuit avec des femme mure femme mure nu porno porno grtuit femme mure salope arabe mure porno amateur femme mure femme mure porno x femme mure free sexe nylon mature free mature and gratuite and femme mure and photo and amateur and photo porno and belle and rencontre coquin femme mure gratuit photo de belle femme mure saint laurent mure 69720 photo femme mure avec jeune rencontre gratuit femme mure fame mure salope porno femme mure lesbienne mature gratuit confiture mure liquide sex mature blonde femme mure x free sex movies mature pantyhose lesbians mature gateau mure mature tit fucking belle femme mure couple mature gratuit femme mature lesbienne et remplie poil sur chatte victoire amatrice libertin mature comment faire des confiture de mure photo porno femme mure video gratuite femme mure photo gratuite amatrice mature rencontrer femme mure recette gelee mure mature amatrice belle mere femme mure gratuit be movies booty afrique mature etiquette confiture mure housewife babe pussy mature mature amatrice gratuit index of mature lesbians parent couple mature sex photo belle femme mature femme mature belle mature blonde fucked galerie sexe mature nude old mature free pic sex mature old and mature hairy old mature insertion natural hairy mature mature galerie gratuite galerie mature poilue photo gratuite mature mature woman free movies french free galerie femme mature old mature mother hole mature spreads pussy gallery pic thumb thumb photo photo fotos photo fuckinn mature woman mature men online galerie mature perso hot boy fucked by mature man free video dvd mature free ass mature chatte mature fat pics mature x old mature photo mature poilue gratuite fat mature pictures tgp females mature new mature tgp mature bitches daily galerie ass fingering mature galery free pic mature boys mature fat girls mature hairy spreading mature old bite free porn movies mature black fucking mature sex mature black mature free anal belle black mature extrait video x femme mature video mature a telecharger mature rousse nu nature black mature fr grosse mature nu mature porn clip mature and tales film gratos lesbian mature free lesbian mature pic tgp mature gode anal gratuit pipi salope mature photo gratuite de femme nu mature porn mature galerie grosse mature gratuit morocco mature porn bite black mature 55 ans home mature fuck grosse poitrine mature sex video mature dog fuck mature salope mature amatrice grosse black mature porno mature black old women mature with young girls lesbian sexy mature women in stocking sexy mature gratuit.com free mature women pics film porno de femme mature mature mom young black women mature femme amateur mature secretaire mature sexy porno mature photo film porno mature mature women nude mature women for sex in westmidlands mature moms porno video young boys familly actrice mature porno mature women naked hot mature young mature bourgeoise salopes.com veille salope com sexy and mature mature asian porno video mature young perso couple amateur mature mature maroc porno vieille mature mure women mature gallery tres vieille mature gratuit vieille femme mature et experience sexuelle mature women with young mature women dating young man uk femme mature porno femme mature cochon sexe free mature femme mature sexe sexe mature gratuis sexe asiatique mature mature ass mature woman femme mur sexe mature mature sexe jeune vieille mature tgp sex amateur mature mature black young mature sex sexy mature femme mature gratuite vieille and mature group mature sex femme mature a gros sein mature femme mature salope mature galerie tgp mature gratuit lady sex mature mature 50 ans gratuit vieille mature gratuit mature salope gratuit photo femme nu mature mature teacher sex femme mature site groups.msn.com gratuit rencontre femme mature belgique transsexuel trav site perso trans sud ouest trans site groups.msn.com site groups.msn.com transsexuel video gratuite rencontre transsexuelle photo gratuit salope travelo webcam travestie transsexuelle moselle metz trans xxx trans paris trans trav sud paca video and trans trans trav club spectacle fr trans e transsexuel fucking trans salope galerie travesti and galerie image and transsexuel and gratuite transsexuelle video gratuite trans sex photo trans page perso transsexuel escorte transsexuel free pics trans sexe transsexuelle sexis trans sud transsexuel tgp transsexuel video gratuite video trans gratuite transsexuel hard crad bresil trans val de marne transsexuelle contact reel transsexuel bresilien perso trans gratuit perso transsexuel operation transsexuelle photo transsexuelle gratuit roman photo transsexuel trans continent tr201d pontiac trans sport occasion recherche tchatche transsexuel gratuit dialoguer photo et adresse gratuite trans independant rencontre transsexuel rencontre trans shemale sur marseille trans continent lecteur enregistreur dvd salope trans pontiac and trans and sport rencontre region transsexuelle pontiac trans am 1979 sex trans gratuit trans continent tr201 porno transsexuelle trans continent firm ware occasion pontiac trans am rencontre trans toulouse tout sur transsexuelle photo belle transsexuelle shemale tranny hermaphrodite trans trans actif france photo transsexuel gratuite photo and trans photo hard transsexuel sex sex trans photo transsexuel gratuit

Across these pages we will try to contribute to the knowledge on the sex and the sexuality.

casimira November 23, 2006 at 7:32 am

Telecharger gratuit rap us carte electronique zapi _
Jeu gratuit a telecharger Cul photo video gratuit _
Telecharger jeu gratuit code sur jeu video _
Telecharger gratuit carte electronique yahoo _
Telecharger emule gratuit Lecture media gratuit video gratuit cul x _
Telecharger antivirus gratuit video de freestyle en moto cross _
Telecharger msn gratuit carte france ville _
Jeu a telecharger gratuit Petite video cul gratuit _
Telecharger film gratuit extrait video porno femme mature _
Telecharger mp3 gratuit carte france tomtom go _
Telecharger jeu video gratuit Video amateur gratuit cul _
Logiciel gratuit a telecharger video porno voir extrait gratuit _
Telecharger jeu pc gratuit carte france telecom _
Telecharger video gratuit Video cul clara morgane gratuit _
Telecharger avast gratuit video moto insolite _
Telecharger film x gratuit carte france suisse _
Film a telecharger gratuit Video cul gratuit voir _
Film gratuit a telecharger video gay entierement gratuite _
Telecharger msn messenger gratuit carte france sud _
Telecharger nero gratuit Video cul sexe gratuit _
Telecharger limewire gratuit bareback gay video gratuite _
Telecharger divx gratuit carte france satellite _
Telecharger emoticone gratuit Video porno cul gratuit _
Telecharger real player gratuit casino video poker _
Antivirus gratuit a telecharger carte france region departement _
Telecharger film divx gratuit Photo cul gratuite _
Telecharger film porno gratuit 3gp video convertisseur _
Telecharger video x gratuit carte france radar automatise _
Telecharger winzip gratuit Photo gratuite cul _
Telecharger shareaza gratuit sexe video gratuit extrait porno _
Telecharger video porno gratuit carte france radar automatiques fr _
Telecharger musique mp3 gratuit Galerie photo cul gratuite _
Jeu gratuit a telecharger gratuitement video insolite cannes 2005 _
Musique a telecharger gratuit

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: