Japan fact of the day

by on August 18, 2007 at 10:46 am in Data Source | Permalink

Analysts estimate that 20 percent of all luxury goods are sold in Japan and another 30 percent to Japanese traveling abroad — meaning Japanese buy half of all luxury goods.  Today, approximately 40 percent of all Japanese own a Vuitton product.

That is from Dana Thomas’s really quite interesting Deluxe: How Luxury Lost its Luster.  Thomas believes that the Japanese are so infatuated with luxury goods because they wish to brand themselves in what otherwise pretends to be a "classless" society.

Wild Pegasus August 18, 2007 at 11:24 am

That’s a good explanation. I think it might be a substitute for not being able to purchase land.

Lord August 18, 2007 at 1:50 pm

If you pay for space what the Japanese do, anything less would be better left vacant.

kvn August 18, 2007 at 3:53 pm

Whatever. The Japanese just appreciate high quality goods.

Anthony August 18, 2007 at 6:01 pm

My Asian (‘being an asian’) perspective:

1) I don’t know where this “Classless” society idea from, but in most Asian country, Japan included, your wealth defines your class, and they seldomly pretend the otherwise. So, other than just simply “vanity consumption” and “peer pressure”, buying an expansive bag is a way to masquerade as a ‘upper’ class. Of course, the truely rich then has to up the war and use other means to signal their wealthiness.

2) Being in a warring society since 12th centuries until before their Meiji restoration, the craftsmanship and other manufacturing skills were cultivated by warlords in order to empower their army. This is a long tradition and has a spillover effect. It is just like the competition of European cities has generally improve the standard of art and clock design.

This is only possible when we fought in old style warfare (usually small and limited in scale, battle ended in days after initial conflict). The ‘Total War’, on the other hand, encourages mass production, and quantity trumps quality (e.g. U.S.A)

Richard Green August 18, 2007 at 7:00 pm

The “classless society” illusion of the post war years is one of the most fascinating aspects when combined with a culture (and language) with so many fine gradients of status.

There may be important regional differences within Japan, for instance between Tokyo, which as the home of power for 400 years is prone to status comparisons, and Osaka, disparaged as a city of merchants. In the former, income is linked to status, and luxry goods are bought as Veblen goods, in the latter, income is linked to what one can buy, and luxury goods are bought as quality goods. I can look at my parents-in-law, from the latter, and note that they have a Mercedes used only to drive to their yacht, but there doesn’t seem to be any status element to the purchase, merely that it’s a good car that they can afford (but don’t need to drive much). This impression is supported by the fact that they produced a daughter who evaluates purchasing products solely on their quality in regards to price (and subsequently buys home brand food products usually).
In fact, I had to explain the concept of class almost entirely when I was mocking both my upper middle class relatives and some noveau riche in the same vicinity.

Dragon Horse August 18, 2007 at 10:01 pm

Before the Meiji Reformation Japan was highly class stratified into castes. The caste were defined by their societal value and “cleanliess” according to Shinto and Buddhist tradition.

The Rank were:

Samurai/Royal Family -There were several divisions of Samurai, not all were wealthy warlords or “knights” some were civil servants, tax collectors, etc.

Artisans – this included Geisha but also smiths, potters, thespians, etc.

Farmers

Merchants – although next to the lowest class because they were seen as a type of parasite, they were often wealthier than many Samurai.

Eta/Burakumin – basically untouchable, because they did jobs that were “dirty”…undertakers, slaughters, etc.

After Meiji the Samurai and extended Royals took various upper-level societal positions from politicians, to professors, high level bureaucrats, military officers.

After WWII, much of the old society was reformed again and gave way to more of a meritocratic system. Many of the old guard were still at the upper levels but there was much movements in the social structure and much less resistant by the old “blue bloods” as compared to in Europe or even America.

This is where the “classless society” comes from.

For instance there are no ghettos in Tokyo (although there are poor who live in poor housing in mixed income neighborhoods). Most people say they are middle class, the income inequality in Japanese society is one of the lowest in the world, CEOs get paid far less than in America.

The Japanese fascination with brand names is an East Asian cultural thing.

Having cool things gives one more “face” in society so they like to have things they can show off.

This is true in Japan, Korea, and China (Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore, etc). I would say that Japanese don’t act as nouveau rich as the Chinese tend to or as overly, “in your face” with their stuff.

A Chinese friend once told me when I asked why he had a 5 year old low end BMW but lived in a relatively crappy apartment…”Most people see what kind of car you drive but most don’t know where you live”. That about sums it up I think.

Barkley Rosser August 19, 2007 at 2:19 pm

The Japanese are not as “nouveau riche” as the Chinese or other Asians, because they have been richer for longer than
the others.

The description of the old class structure of Japanese society given above was sorely hurting in several ways.
The royal family and the samurai were not on the same level. In between them was the aristocracy, the noble
lords, who were definitely below the royal family, but were above the samurai. The samurai worked for the
aristocrats and were loyal to specific ones, except for the unattached ones, who certainly were not at the top
of the social scale on par with the royal family. After all, the emperor was a god. None of these others was.

Dragon Horse August 19, 2007 at 5:20 pm

Ray:

I lived there from 2001-2002…most of that stuff is not really true anymore.

White skin is still favored by women, but often you will see tan Japanese men on TV, which makes the skin color difference extreme between people of the same ethnicity. My wife (who is Japanese) told me it looks more “manly”.

I don’t think this is true in Korea, as when we visited all the guys on TV are as pale as the women. Japan goes through a lot of fads though, in the late 1990′s a lot young girls (and some guys) kogaru would spend a lot of money to tan themselves as dark as possible which older people found disgusting but it was quite popular. Now that fad has faded. Dyed hair (blond, red, auburn) was also quite popular but now black hair/dark brown is back in style. This also bled into when hip hop started spreading into the Japanese teen mainstream.

White car thing? Never heard of it, probably another fad (ryuko).

I never had an issue of people not sitting next to me in Tokyo (where I lived). Now if you go outside of Tokyo that is a little different. I notice that older women are the least likely to sit next to foreigners, younger men are the most likely. My wife told me they think foreigners smell bad. I sat next to some continental European once on the train and yeah he smelled bad as they don’t wash or use deodorant as much as American. I wouldn’t be surprised if that stereotype came from Europeans in Japan.

I would say if you are ever on a bus in Hong Kong in the summer some people don’t smell so great either, but I noticed in Japan, even men in suits don’t sweat much in the summer and I never met a Japanese guy who ‘smelled’(other than the homeless people in the stations). My wife thinks it is diet. She says Japanese people often say gaijin smell like meat/butter. Could be.

Barkley

For this topic I didn’t feel it was necessary to differentiate between Royal Family/Daimyo/Samurai.

The Royal Family routinely married with the Daimyo and especially with the clan of the Shogunate in power.

Samurai were loyal to the Daimyo or directly to the Shogunate..blah blah blah…point was there strict class differences

In some ways the Japanese system was very much like Medieval Europe, much more than China was as China routinely had peasant emperors (due to the mandate of heaven) and a meritocratic system of sorts that created powerful civil servants, many of who came from humble backgrounds. There is much less class mobility but then again the Tokugawa thought this up and I’m not sure exactly when it was initiated but that shogunate lasted from 1603 to the Meiji Restoration so before that I’m not sure.

In any case I don’t believe Japanese are really class consciousness in the Western science. Wanting to show off certain things due to status is not “class” as we think of in Western Europe, which is based far more on family.

russ August 19, 2007 at 8:18 pm

Why don’t the japanese have any luxury goods houses like the West does? Or do they?

Barkley Rosser August 20, 2007 at 2:22 pm

Regarding luxury goods stores, there are specialty stores like Tiffany and Harry Winston.
In terms of a more general luxury goods store, the most famous is Wako in the heart of the
Ginza, the most valuable real estate area in the world. The building it is located in is
famously one of the few in Tokyo to survive the WW II firebombing of the city, with the
imperial palace (consciously not bombed), the Diet building (which looks a lot like the
LA city hall), the Kabuki theater not far from Wako, and the main building of the central
railroad station (along with some temples and shrines), being among the few others to do so.

Regarding Okinawa, it is the poorest part of Japan and was long the center of the independent
kingdom of the Ryukyus, which was allied more with China than Japan, as was Korea, until the
late nineteenth century, when the Japanese came in. The Okinawans have their own dialect, now
mostly faded, but a continuing sense of a distinct ethnic identity, including a distinct cuisine
and their own distinctive (and spicey) form of sake, known as awamori.

Regarding class, it is clear that as time has gone on, with major breaks both with the Meiji
Restoration that basically ended the power of the samurai, and after WW II, the old hereditary
based class system has pretty much broken down, although apparently the Eta/Burakumin continue
to be discriminated against. Otherwise, education matters, and if one can get into one of the
top universities, with the University of Tokyo at the pinnacle, one can get into the upper
levels of the hierarchy, which depend on positions in the government or major keiretsu businesses,
with income tending to correspond to those levels.

There is definite hierarchy, but it is not nearly as much tied to heredity as it used to be.

neko August 21, 2007 at 9:35 am

various reasons…

like the first post, japanese people have a hard time buying property. it’s much easier to buy luxury goods than buy luxury property. also,as japanese people live in tiny housing (and live in a moderate climate), they go outside where they are many people who are much more critical of presentation. recall that japanese people have a mentality of “uchi” and “soto” — outside, and inside– the way they present and interact with those on the outside and inside are v different. count the number of women on tokyo public transport who dont wear makeup or respond to a question with an artificial pitch.

quite a few japanese people also have a fair bit of disposable income to spend on luxury goods, particularly if they are young women living at home, first sons living at home (who will inherit the house and carry the family name), etc. — v little spending on rent, food, etc.

the japanese are also late developers who’d like to be considered part of the western league of advanced nations. maybe after purchases of european material wealth make the japanese feel better about how they’ve managed to catch up, and feel slightly more “western” they will spend more of their money elsewhere.

无缝管 November 13, 2007 at 8:15 pm

Hi Best wishes。Allow me to offer my heartiest wishes.xicao loves-流水线娱乐博客常年提供高、中、低压锅炉钢管、流体钢管、结构钢管、化肥专用钢管、石油裂化钢管、地质钢管、液压支柱钢管及合金钢管-无缝管-无缝钢管等论文发表资讯/刊物信息,协助客户制定论文发表方案

China tour November 27, 2007 at 2:35 am

China Tours and Yangtze Cruises A professional China travel agency offering private & group package tours, tailor-made vacations for families, couples and individual travelers, Yangtze cruises, hotel & ticket booking services.

China Travel and Tours One-stop China travel service delivering China package tours, discount Yangtze River cruises and best rate hotels.

Tibet Train Travel A reliable tour operator specializing in Tibet tour packages, adventures, hotel and train ticket booking.

China Maps A free web-based source for China travel and tour map users

Voyage Chine, Tour de Chine, Circuit Chine – Un agence spécialiste voyage en Chine

Great Wall of China A website for the Great Wall of China.

hiu November 27, 2007 at 7:18 am

転職今週のピックアップ / 求人情報 ◆◇◆ 注目案件はこちら!!
【女性の転職情報】◆化粧品、婦人雑貨の輸入販売会社 / システムエンジニア 【女性の転職情報】◆海外高級ブランドコスメ / WEBマスター 【女性の転職情報】◆シニア向け住宅等の開発・運営会社 / 経理スタッフ 【女性の転職情報】◆女性活躍中!! / シニア向け住宅企画開発 【女性の転職情報】◆キャリアが活かせる!本社勤務 / 経理スタッフ 【女性の転職情報】◆未経験歓迎、経験者優遇 / エステティシャン 【女性の転職情報】◆通販を主とした化粧品メーカー / 企画営業職 【女性の転職情報】◆大手貴金属メーカーのオリジナル化粧品部門 / 販促企画

nghn November 27, 2007 at 7:23 am

ホスト全国各地の提携ホストクラブ情報をご紹介します。ホストになってみたい方だけでなくホストクラブ
に行ってみたい方も是非ご覧下さい。このホームペ
ージは18歳未満の方の閲覧をお断りしております。
「夢」「光」「希望」リッチな生活があなたを待っています
君のライフスタイルにあわせて、3種類から選べます!
①日給10,000円~+指名料+売り上げパック+賞金
②月給25万円以上+能率級
③時給制(応相談)
マンション寮完備、スーツ無料貸与、日払いOK、
各種報奨金、海外慰安旅行年3回、体験入店制度あり、
専属ヘアメイク在中
年齢:18歳以上(未経験者も大歓迎。全力で夢を追え
る人、大募集です)
業種:①ホスト②ホールスタッフ

鑽石 April 2, 2008 at 9:54 pm

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: