Merit-based gifts

by on August 9, 2007 at 7:13 am in Philosophy | Permalink

Last week I gave Bryan Caplan a gift.  Not being much of an egalitarian, I explained the gift on the grounds that he is extremely meritorious.

What if we generally gave gifts on the basis of sheer personal merit?

Most gifts are for "occasions," such as birthdays and Christmas.  The value of the gift may be correlated with how the giver perceives the merit of the recipient, but rarely is merit the pretext for the gift.  Perhaps a general practice of explicit merit-based gift-giving would create too many perceived slights.  In contrast, when a holiday is the pretext and the value of the gift is (possibly) linked to merit, we can self-deceive and believe that a small-valued gift simply represents a cheap gift-giver, or a friendship of uncertain strength, rather than our own lack of merit.

But every now and then it is important to stand up to social convention and do what is right.  Please give a merit-based gift — to someone who deserves it — sometime this month. 

sa August 9, 2007 at 7:23 am

i’ll ask my boss for a raise. the joy of giving!

Nadav August 9, 2007 at 8:28 am

I remember reading that Charlie Munger, Warren Buffett’s partner, gave a gift of a few Berkshire Hathaway shares to Professor Robert Cialdini (who wrote “Influence”) just because he liked his work so much.

Which billionaire would be most likely to do the same for Professor Cowen?

PEG August 9, 2007 at 8:53 am

Christmas and birthday presents ARE merit-based gifts, as long as you decide that the value of the gift will be proportional to the merit of the receiver (“Have you been a good boy this year?”).

In that case, Christmas Eve and the birthday is no longer an occasion — it’s a deadline.

Andy August 9, 2007 at 9:18 am

What is merit?

Jeffrey Horn August 9, 2007 at 10:13 am

Wouldn’t it be a better strategy (from a risk perspective) for each person to give according to the utility they gain from giving the gift? Merit shouldn’t play a role in the decision beyond how much we think the person will benefit from the gift.

Giving a quality gift on the basis of a subjective analysis of another person’s merit is no different than giving CEOs bonuses and stock options. Which would be fine if the person you are treating this way is your agent.

But your child, or your grandmother? That may teach the wrong values (i.e. it may miss the value of charity altogether) or may give your gift some kind of chilling and impersonal trait.

Be human.

mobile August 9, 2007 at 11:32 am

To the extent that merit is correlated with the quantity and quality of
personal relationships, so is your holiday and birthday booty.

Andromeda August 9, 2007 at 1:51 pm

Sent a care package earlier today. Way ahead of you :) .

Mathew August 9, 2007 at 2:47 pm

I’m not sure gift-giving practices evolved from feelings of egalitarianism. Whenever I think about what kind of gift would be good for a person, I ask myself what might benefit their life that they would not buy themselves.

I understand the rationality arguments about people choosing what’s best for them, and while it might be generally true, it’s certainly not specifically true. People have their blind spots. People also have their personal religions — established habits — that keep them from acquiring some things that usually don’t add utility, but might in rare circumstances.

It’s easier to see somebody’s blind spots than your own just like it’s easier to see another person’s personal problems than it is your own. So, a society of gift-givers might become stronger — in the very same way that a society of traders becomes stronger: a net benefit of utility. And in particular, there may be no other way (until pervasive AI) to achieve those utility benefits.

Eh, it’s just a thought.

George August 9, 2007 at 9:41 pm

Gifts given on the basis of merit are, in fact, not gifts at all.

brent August 10, 2007 at 11:07 am

To the extent that merit based gifts provide an additional positive feedback loop, I can see the value in merit based gifts. How else to express your admiration of a peer or friends work than with a nice bottle of wine, or whiskey (to be split between the gifter and giftee, of course).

sent August 15, 2007 at 3:09 am

轻型货架
中型货架
重型货架
海宁货架
金华货架
永嘉货架
宁波模具架
悬臂货架
阁楼货架
工业货架
汽车4S店货架
仓储笼
苏州仓储笼
宁波仓储笼
轻型货架
无锡货架
液压搬运车
轻型货架
南通货架
轻型货架
重型货架
杭州货架
宁波货架
衢州货架
余姚货架
重型货架
无锡货架
苏州货架
合肥货架
九江货架
临安货架
常州料箱
连云港料箱
淮阴料箱
徐州料箱
盐城料箱
扬州料箱
南通钢制料箱
镇江料箱
南京料箱
无锡料箱
嘉善料箱
慈溪料箱
萧山料箱
金华料箱
绍兴料箱
宁波料箱
昆山料箱
吴江料箱
张家港料箱
江阴料箱
丹阳料箱
无锡料箱
常州料箱
淮阴料箱
徐州料箱
盐城料箱
扬州料箱
南通料箱
苏州料箱
镇江料箱
南京料箱
阁楼货架
模具货架
悬臂货架
重型货架
中型货架
轻型货架
句容货架
舟山货架
淮阴货架
南京货架
南通货架
吴江货架
山东货架
扬中货架
镇江货架
义乌货架
无锡货架
余姚货架
温州货架
绍兴货架
嘉兴货架
金华货架
宁波货架
下沙货架
杭州货架
中型货架
重型货架
江都货架
æ³°å·žè´§æž¶
太仓货架
昆山货架
吴江货架
张家港货架
常熟货架
溧阳货架
金坛货架
扬中货架
丹阳货架
淮阴货架
无锡货架
常州货架
徐州货架
金华仓储笼
衢州仓储笼
萧山仓储笼
义乌仓储笼
慈溪仓储笼
诸暨仓储笼
舟山仓储笼
瑞安仓储笼
无锡仓储笼
扬州仓储笼
镇江仓储笼
江阴仓储笼
张家港仓储笼
金坛仓储笼
吴江仓储笼
南通仓储笼
镇江塑料托盘
扬州塑料托盘
无锡塑料托盘
塑料托盘
求购货架
轻型货架
中型货架
托盘货架
贯通货架
马鞍山仓储笼
宁波重型货架
杭州轻型货架
杭州中型货架
杭州重型货架
杭州悬臂架
杭州4S店货架
宁波轻型货架
宁波中型货架
永嘉仓储笼
丽水仓储笼
温州仓储笼
台州仓储笼
绍兴仓储笼
宁波仓储笼
嘉兴仓储笼
宁波仓储笼
杭州仓储笼
盐城货架
南通货架
苏州货架
镇江货架
南京货架
工业货架
轻型货架
中型货架
重型货架
悬臂货架
零配件库房货架
仓储货架
上海货架
浙江货架
角钢货架
部队货架
萧山货架
é•¿å…´è´§æž¶
永嘉货架
海宁货架
富阳货架
松阳货架
龙泉货架
宁海货架
瑞安货架
兰溪货架
永康货架
温岭货架
义乌货架
金华货架
临海货架
æ¹–å·žè´§æž¶
绍兴货架
宁波货架
杭州货架
杭州货架
杭州货架
è´§æž¶
角钢货架
轻型货架
重型货架
悬臂货架
模具货架
阁楼货架
工业货架
仓库货架
大连货架
安徽货架
部队货架
无锡货架
江西货架
江阴货架
汽车4S店货架
重型货架
仓储笼
托盘
登高车
塑料托盘
物流台车
贯通货架
轻型货架
中型货架
杭州货架
绍兴货架
金华货架
é•¿å…´è´§æž¶
余姚货架
济南仓储笼
登高车
挂板架
4S店货架
堆垛架
苏州货架
南通货架
扬州货架
盐城货架
徐州货架
淮阴货架
连云港货架
常州货架
丹阳货架
金坛货架
常熟货架
无锡货架
南京货架
镇江货架
嘉兴货架
æ¹–å·žè´§æž¶
杭州货架
隔离网片
贯通式货架
模具货架
悬臂货架
重型货架
中型货架
轻型货架
嘉兴货架
宁波货架
绍兴货架
台州货架
温州货架
金华货架
衢州货架
余杭货架
诸暨货架
慈溪货架
瑞安货架
义乌货架
货架厂
汽车4S店货架
杭州货架
æ¹–å·žè´§æž¶
阁楼货架
悬臂货架
模具架
中型货架
温州货架
重型货架
仓储笼
货位式货架
重型货架
登高车
阁楼货架
轻型货架
中型货架
悬臂货架
仓库货架
轻型货架
è´§æž¶
è´§æž¶
物料整理架
托盘
钢托盘
货箱|料箱
物流台车
工具柜
工具车
工作台|
整理柜
手推车
仓储笼
堆垛架
登高车
置物架
搬运车
堆高车
è´§æž¶
è´§æž¶
南京货架
苏州货架
无锡货架
常州货架
连云港货架
淮阴货架
盐城货架
扬州货架
南通货架
昆山货架
张家港货架
宜兴货架
江阴货架
淮安货架
常熟货架
æ³°å…´è´§æž¶
è´§æž¶
吴江货架
太仓货架
滨海货架
金湖货架
靖江货架
江苏货架
公司简介
公司简介
杭州货架
温州货架
宁波货架
绍兴市货架
嘉兴货架
临海货架
金华货架
台州货架
温岭货架
舟山货架|
移动式货架
滚轮式货架
悬臂货架
阁楼货架
模具货架
贯通式货架
重型货架
中型货架
轻型货架
角钢货架
è´§æž¶
移动式货架
滚轮式货架
悬臂货架
阁楼货架
模具货架
贯通式货架
重型货架
中型货架
è´§æž¶

鑽石 April 2, 2008 at 9:39 pm

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: