Assorted links

by on September 1, 2010 at 11:44 am in Web/Tech | Permalink

1. In defense of factory employment.

2. Bill Dickens defends education against the signaling model.

3. In defense of links.

kramer@johnsonmatic.com September 1, 2010 at 12:44 pm
dearieme September 1, 2010 at 1:43 pm

Mr Dickens certainly puts up a spiritedly panglossian defence. His argument, however, proves too much. His logic applies not just to American education in total, but to each part of it. So let me pick a part where his argument that all is for the best in this best of all possible worlds is obviously wrong – legal education. As I understand it, to be a lawyer in the US the system you leave school at 18 or so, do a four-year undergraduate degree, then a three yar postgaduate degree, then take your bar exams. Now you are 25 or more, have no work experience as a lawyer, and are probably deep in debt. Other common law countries do it differently. For example in England, you leave school and:-
†¢ Degree in law – three years full-time
†¢ Legal Practice Course – one year full-time
†¢ Practice-based training (training contract) incorporating the Professional Skills Course
– two years full-time
†¢ Admission to the roll of solicitors.

By the time you are 25 you have passed all your exams, have had two years apprenticeship experience in a law office and one year’s full professional practice under your belt. Your debts are far lower – and may indeed already be paid off; after all, you’ve been drawing a salary for three years. Since that is (it seems to me) a manifestly better system for everyone except the teachers and administrators in US universities, I think it stands as a demonstration that Mr Dickens is wrong.

farmer September 1, 2010 at 5:10 pm

@dearieme:
“three year degree” in law vrs “four year undergrad” isn’t how it actually plays out. The UK has lower and upper sixth (A-Levels), whereas american high school students leave for uni in what would be the ned of lower sixth form. So it’s 5 years of high school and 3 years of uni versus 4 and four.
(america behaves as Scotland in this regard)

Jazzie30 September 2, 2010 at 10:12 am

I’m so glad to drop by your site and read your post. Thanks for this information.

school grants

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: