1. In defense of factory employment.
2. Bill Dickens defends education against the signaling model.
by Tyler Cowen on September 1, 2010 at 11:44 am in Web/Tech | Permalink
Previous post: What I’ve been reading
Next post: Venezuelan markets in everything













Get smart with the Thesis WordPress Theme from DIYthemes.
we got this for calenders out in space if we ever need it.
http://www.bing.com/videos/watch/video/marilyn-monroe-vs-briggite-bardot/79dd777be3b2f4c31ec679dd777be3b2f4c31ec6-208791209212?q=bridget%20bardot&FORM=VIRE1
Mr Dickens certainly puts up a spiritedly panglossian defence. His argument, however, proves too much. His logic applies not just to American education in total, but to each part of it. So let me pick a part where his argument that all is for the best in this best of all possible worlds is obviously wrong – legal education. As I understand it, to be a lawyer in the US the system you leave school at 18 or so, do a four-year undergraduate degree, then a three yar postgaduate degree, then take your bar exams. Now you are 25 or more, have no work experience as a lawyer, and are probably deep in debt. Other common law countries do it differently. For example in England, you leave school and:-
†¢ Degree in law – three years full-time
†¢ Legal Practice Course – one year full-time
†¢ Practice-based training (training contract) incorporating the Professional Skills Course
– two years full-time
†¢ Admission to the roll of solicitors.
By the time you are 25 you have passed all your exams, have had two years apprenticeship experience in a law office and one year’s full professional practice under your belt. Your debts are far lower – and may indeed already be paid off; after all, you’ve been drawing a salary for three years. Since that is (it seems to me) a manifestly better system for everyone except the teachers and administrators in US universities, I think it stands as a demonstration that Mr Dickens is wrong.
@dearieme:
“three year degree” in law vrs “four year undergrad” isn’t how it actually plays out. The UK has lower and upper sixth (A-Levels), whereas american high school students leave for uni in what would be the ned of lower sixth form. So it’s 5 years of high school and 3 years of uni versus 4 and four.
(america behaves as Scotland in this regard)
I’m so glad to drop by your site and read your post. Thanks for this information.
school grants
Comments on this entry are closed.