Can America hold Great Britain together through haggis importation?

The British government is pulling out all the stops for Scotland with a referendum on independence two months away, going so far as to lobby the United States government to allow the importation of that famous Scottish delicacy made from sheep’s innards, haggis.

The problem, it seems, is sheep lungs, which the United States banned for consumption in 1971. But lungs are vital to traditional haggis, which usually also contains minced sheep heart and liver, mixed with onion, oatmeal, suet and spices. It’s all stuffed into a sheep’s stomach, which is then simmered for several hours. Delicious, no?

There is more here.  But is the market really there?  I hope not.  Please keep this in mind:

There is apparently a shocking lack of knowledge about haggis. According to a not-very-scientific online survey in 2003, carried out by the haggis manufacturer Hall’s of Broxburn, a third of American visitors to Scotland believed that haggis was an animal. Nearly a quarter thought they could catch one.


Haggis is not the real issue, of course -- it can easily be prepared with American (or other non-British) sheep to meet any possible market demand.

British sheep organ imports were/are rightly banned in America due to the serious British Mad Cow Disease outbreak and related sheep infections, years ago. There is still strong uncertainty in Britain whether that disease vector and related strains has been fully eliminated. Hold the (British) Haggis, please.

Also note that the infectious agent for Mad Cow Disease and scrapie cannot be killed by canning or any conventional form of sterilization. It is a protein, and nothing short of tearing all of the proteins apart will kill it.

I went to a pub in NY which offered haggis as an appetizer, but we ordered something else. But haggis made in the US would have to omit the lung, if the quote above is accurate. Presumably a Scot would say that that NY haggis therefore would not taste right.

Here's the current status of BSE in North America, by the way: 4 identified cases in the US, 18 in Canada, since 2003.


In 1971 BSE was not known about. The first confirmed case was in 1986. I don't think the original ban was particularly evidenced based. It seems like it was a mixture of paranoia and perhaps a little protectionism. Both the USDA and the FDA are often over zealous (and in other cases the FDA works hand in glove with the drug companies to cover stuff up. And just think about it - if haggis per se was so bad then where are the deleterious health effects attributable to in Europe and much of the rest of the world. When it comes to banning foods the USA is way too much of a nanny state.

And why does Tyler say "But is the market really there? I hope not." Why would he not want people to eat haggis? If it's OK to eat beef and chicken why not sheep's lung? I don't understand why he would 'hope not'.

I just had haggis for the first time about a week ago. It reminded me very much of meatloaf in taste and texture. I'm not really sure how big of a market there would be for it here.

Haggis is not eaten for culinary reasons. It is eaten for cultural idenitfication purposes, like Hákarl.ákarl

Poverty diet.

What makes you feel entitled to make broad-sweep statements based on such narrow opinions of food? Plenty of people eat haggis because they like it.

There are also people who say they like Marmite. They're liars.

I've had Haggis once.

Ridiculous desperation is sure to win back the Scottish Lassie's heart.

This is simple trade negotiation.

We accept their haggis, and

They accept

Our GMO.

Had haggis and whisky in Oban, Scotland, years ago. Liked it. Went quite mad in consequence, voting Democrat, paying taxes, and suchlike. Want more of the real stuff. Bring on the imports.

One function of the bustle and the hoopskirt was to make the waist
look smaller and to enhance the bust. So, all
of them will buy a pair of beautiful chinese embroidered
shoes without any hesitant. By searching on the net,
one can find hundreds of fashion industry portals where all kinds of information related to
European fashion are available in detail.

I've also had haggis, and I say this whenever the question of its "foulness" comes up: Put a McD's Quarter Pounder patty in the fridge until cool. Eat.

Boom. THAT is the flavor of haggis.

Tastes nothing like that.

Didn't Gahan Wilson have a cartoon where someone said "I love to see the wild haggis romp."? Say, 40 years ago?

To tan the face, have the customer close their eyes, take a deep breath and then you should begin tanning at the
forehead and work down. - To create contours around the cheek area, add a little extra tanning
product to enhance these areas. In this type, you just fix this particular machine within your
shower, and then you enter inside as white-colored and omit as bronze.
Why I asked, she replied "not only are they the best skin care products, but if Vogue, Cosmo and Professional Beauty Magazines use them I can't be wrong".

He actually started the telethons "Night of Too Many Stars" for the charity New York Collaborates for Autism.
Everyone wants to have a healthy glow, but as we have all learned in recent
years, tanning either naturally or artificially can be dangerous.

With proper cleansing you can also get rid of the dead skin that can build up on the
area. Allow the oil to soak into the body for at least 20
minutes and then wash it and the unsightly blotches away. Dark self
tan can now be achieved from the comfort of your home. An IPL device uses the non-invasive
way for eliminating undesirable hair and is very well-known.

25% of every population is below average intelligence.

If the survey had option of the sort "(d) haggis is an animal (e) haggis is an animal and you might be able to catch it on this trip" then they are just begging for the sort of results they are getting.

More than idiot Americans this sort of thing reinforces the dumb survey designer stereotype.

The thing with that question is, depending on the circumstances asked, I would say yes, Haggis is an animal. It is made from sheep and you could catch a sheep if the farmer didn't shoot you first.

This isn't lack of intelligence, but ignorance. You and I could be caught easily in a similar word-trap somewhere in Cameroon. After all, Scotland is a tiny part of the world and its culinary specialities may be utterly unknown in non-WASP America.

There's a book waiting for an economist who is interested in food about the economics of poverty food and how frequently you have had to be hungry to figure out how to make something taste good, or at least edible without gagging. Snails and haggis have to be at the top of the list? Perhaps potatoes also shpild be included which are relatively inedible uncooked. Recent food shortages in places like Cambodia also serve as examples, fried spiders anyone?

There's quite an story of human endurance in this.

Barbacoa, lengua, and ojos too - someone had to be the first to say "Hey, they're just throwing away the head of that steer, lots of good eatin' there."

" a third of American visitors to Scotland believed that haggis was an animal. Nearly a quarter thought they could catch one."

Catching one would be difficult for as Spike Milligan explained they have legs longer on one side of the body than the other so that they can run around the hills more quickly.

All I can say is that if this is what the British government is down to to prevent Scottish independence, then they are doomed.

Where does this come from? "But is the market really there? I hope not." Has TC tried haggis, and found it wanting? Does he oppose the consumption of sheep organ meat? Would haggis makers vie for strip mall restaurant space, thereby driving up the price of authentic Asian food in the DC metro area?

Oh, I also meant to mention that while in Scotland, locals jokingly told stories about haggis animals. One of them tried to convince me that the haggis was a little rodent-line creature that was hunted to extinction in the 19th century. That survey regarding haggis knowledge may reflect that Americans simply didn't get the joke.

"But is the market really there? I hope not."

You hope not? Why?

If Scotland votes for independence and USA continues to refuse haggis imports this will result in a trade war. Retaliation will focus on that key USA export to Scotland: golfers; they can be banned from playing at St. Andrews. This should create sufficient pressure for the haggis ban to be lifted. Although this does raise the question will Scottish courses be part of the British Open round if Scotland votes yes for Independence.

But should USA see sense and allow imports of haggis then the next thing proposed for export will be white pudding followed by black pudding. I see no mention of these culinary delights here but they can often be on the same plate at breakfast with the noble haggis.

Not commonly known, is the feature of the haggis, that the legs on the left side of the body are shorter than the legs on the right side of the body. This is to allow it to run around hills with ease. Or so it is said. In a debate on the mythical nature of the haggis with an Australian, I silenced him by saying why was I expected to believe in a creature that hopped about on two legs and kept its baby in it stomach. He seemed to think that was a fair point but held to the view that the kangaroo was real. Let us not mention the Loch Ness monster either.

Comments for this post are closed