The roots of structural unemployment

by on March 17, 2007 at 1:20 pm in Economics | Permalink

English economist Andrew Oswald
has shown that across European countries, and across U.S. states, high
levels of home ownership are correlated with high levels of
unemployment.  More conventional factors such as generous welfare
benefits or high levels of unionization don’t explain unemployment
nearly as well as the tendency to own houses.  Renting your home and
staying flexible do wonders for your chances of always finding an
interesting job to do.

Tim Harford has more.

1 squik March 17, 2007 at 1:58 pm

Are you trying to be droll? Renting a house means you must have a source of funds to pay the rent. Once you own a home outright, you have a major expense off your back and thus may be able to afford to be unemployed.

2 spencer March 17, 2007 at 3:02 pm

What paper discusses this?

I looked at several of his papers and could not find this issue.

I suspect there is something about demographics that generates these results.

Probably the individual that has the most trouble finding a new job
is a laid off 55 year old homeowner. But is this because the individual
is a homeowner or because they are 55? Conversely, a 25 year old renter
probably finds a new job much quicker. But is this because they or a
renter or because they are 25?

3 spencer March 17, 2007 at 3:28 pm

There are a whole host of reasons why a 55 year old will have more difficulty and I had not even considered the pension factor.

Basically I was thinking more of the factor that the 55 year old will be looking for a senior position using their experience that pays much more while the 25 year old will be looking for a lower paying job and does not have so much embedded capital that he will try to earn a return on. For example, a 55 year old aerospace engineer will be looking for something that will use his education and experience in aerospace while the 25 year old will not be looking for such a narrowly defined job category and is much more willing to change fields even if they have a narrow formal education–as an aerospace engineer for example.

Moreover, the job structure is like a pyramid so that the higher you go the smaller and smaller the number of jobs become. Consequently, the 55 year old with higher pay expectations will just find fewer job opportunities then the 25 year old with lower expectations– or in economic terms a lower reservation wage. I do not know what the current data is, but headhunters have always had a rule of thumb that the higher the salary the longer the job search.

In general, doesn’t the switch to defined benefits means that the pension issue is becoming less and less significant over time?

4 Foobarista March 17, 2007 at 4:51 pm

This would seem obvious if one remembers that high-cost areas have both lots of renters and are likely to have lower levels of unemployment. All this study correlates to is the fact that cheap areas with fewer renters are areas without much economic activity.

5 Ronald Brak March 17, 2007 at 5:53 pm

So a policy prescription to reduce unemployment would be to reduce the cost of buying and selling homes?
For example, eliminating stamp duty on home purchases. (That is if you have stamp duty in the U.S.)

6 dearieme March 17, 2007 at 8:20 pm

Obviously the unemployed buy houses because they have the leisure time to improve and decorate them. No-one would bother improving a rented house.

7 triticale March 17, 2007 at 11:17 pm

I’m 56. I own my home outright. I have a specialized technical telecom skill which pays pretty well when I’m needed, and I spend about a quarter of my time unemployed. My wee wifey works in health care, and thus gets excellent benefit coverage for the two of us.

8 josh March 18, 2007 at 9:34 am

“But is this because the individual
is a homeowner or because they are 55? Conversely, a 25 year old renter
probably finds a new job much quicker. But is this because they or a
renter or because they are 25?”

Good point, but I hope they would have adjusted for demographics.

9 Blissex March 18, 2007 at 2:17 pm

Some UK conservative think tank did a study 20 years ago that showed that voting for parties of the right correlated very highly with home and car ownership, and as a result the Thatcher government gave away a lot of houses and discouraged public transport, and now the UK has a permanent majority of right wing voters…

It may be that when most voters are home and asset owners they tend to vote for parties of the right who don’t care that much, or wors, about unemployment, or underemployment.

Consider the UK 20 years later, today: the government is so keen on protecting the interests of middle aged or retired home and asset owners (which are the majority of voters) that it has adopted policies designed to harm low end salaries and raise unemployment of the young.

Then as others have pointed out home owners tend to find it harder to get jobs as they are middle aged, and also have less urgency to do so as they don’t need to pay rent and have savings to tide them over.

10 Martin March 19, 2007 at 3:48 am


“This is simply idiotic. Arguing in this vein, I could point out that humans were nomadic hunter-gatherers for many more millenia, so we should give up on the idea of permanent shelter altogether, and it would be stupid, but still not quite as stupid as this argument.”

Play the ball, son, not the man.

The argument is not anti economics; but it is most certainly anti-economist.

11 Ricky March 19, 2007 at 8:04 pm

The data probably should show that more ownership in homes will correlate to higher unemployment. Once most people dive into the ownership in a home they tend to root themselves into that area for a few years. If people are renting out a place it is much easier to relocate quickly and not have too many problems. If an unemployed worker is renting it only makes sense that it will be easier for them to find a job they want and be capable of moving to get the job.

12 pgtlvihqaa March 20, 2007 at 6:53 am
13 hvtoxelttj March 20, 2007 at 6:54 am

male male older men spanking sites

14 biggyrl May 9, 2007 at 5:55 pm

I am a 25 year old record lable C.E.O.. If you want to ball out of Control you need to do this. I have made $10,000 in about a month and I have so much Music Equipment it’s ridiculous. So if you need some dough, loot, money whatever you call it just read this and follow the instructions and the money will start pouring in.

I’m sure you’ve read these letters asking you to send $1 to 6 different addresses. Putting your home address on the internet can be risky, but through paypal all you have to provide is your email address. It’s safe and easy just go to and set up your account!!!! I am not a gullible person and have never trusted things like this, but I gave it a try, hey its only $6, I figured at least 6 people would respond out of the millions of people that use the internet. You should give it a try too! You have nothing to lose, and thousands to gain! Read on for the letter that I found …

A little while back, I was browsing through newsgroup, just like you are now and came across an article similar to this that said you could make thousands dollars within weeks with only an initial investment of $6.00! So I thought, “Yeah, right, this must be a scam”, but like most of us, I was curious, so I kept reading. Anyway, it said that you send $1.00 though paypal to each of the emails stated in the article. You then place your own email address in the bottom of the list at #6, and post the article in at least 200 news groups. (There are thousands) No catch that was it. So after thinking it over, and talking to few people first, I thought about trying it. I figured what have I got to lose except $6.00, right? Like most of us I was a little skeptical and a little worried about the legal aspects of it. It follows the same regulations as the “mailed chain letters, which according to the U.S. Post Office (1-800-725-2161) is indeed legal! Then I invested the measly $6.00. Well GUESS WHAT!!? Within 7 days, I started getting money in my paypal account! I was shocked! I figured it would end soon, but the money just kept coming in. In my first week, I made about $20.00. By the end second week I had made a total over $1,200.00!!! In the third week I had over $10,000.00 and it’s still growing. This is now my fourth week and I have made a total of just over $36,000.00 and it’s still coming in rapidly. It’s Certainly worth $6.00. I have spent more than that on the lottery!! Let me tell you how this works and most importantly, why it works? Also, make sure you print a copy of this article NOW, so you can get the information off of it as you need it.

$$ REQUIREMENTS: You must have a verified paypal account. If you do not have an account you can go to and follow the instructions to set up a free account. In order to place the initial $6 into your account, you will have to verify your bank account with paypal (which may take a few days). Paypal is 100% secure and is used by millions of people world wide.

STEP 1: Send, through paypal, $1.00 to each email on the below list. Make the subject of the payment “Email List” and in the comments, write “PLEASE PUT ME ON YOUR EMAIL LIST.” What you are doing is creating a service by this and best of all you are not giving your address to anyone you do not know … THIS IS ABSOLUTELY LEGAL! The email list:


STEP 2: Now take the #1 email off the list that you see above, move the other addresses up (6 becomes 5, 5 becomes 4, etc) and add YOUR email address (the one used on the paypal account) as number 6 on the list.

STEP 3: Change anything you need to, but try to keep this article as close to original as possible. Now, post your amended article to at least 200 newsgroups, message board. (I think there are close to 32,000 groups) All you need is 200, but remember, the more you post, the more money you make – as well as everyone else on the list!


Step #1) You do not need to re-type this entire letter to do your own posting. Simply put your CURSOR at the beginning of this letter and drag your CURSOR to the bottom of this document, and select ‘copy’ from the edit menu. This will copy the entire letter into the computer memory.

Step #2) Open a blank ‘notepad’ file and place your cursor at the top of the blank page. From the ‘edit’ menu select ‘paste’. This will paste a copy of the letter into notepad so that you can add your name to the list.

Steps #3) save your new notepad file as a .txt file. If you want to do your postings in different sittings, you’ll always have this file to go back to.

Step #4) Use Netscape or Internet Explorer and try searching for various newsgroups, on-line forums, message boards, bulletin boards, chat sites, discussions, discussion groups, online communities, etc. For example: you log on to any search engine like,,, then you search with subject like ?millionaire message board? or ?money making message board? or ?employment message board? or ?money making discussions? or ?money making forum? or ?business message board? etc. You will find thousands & thousands of message boards. Click them one by one then you will find the option to post a new message.

Step #5) Visit these message boards and post this article as a new message by highlighting the text of this letter and selecting paste from the Edit menu. Fill in the Subject, this will be the header that everyone sees as they scroll thru the list of postings in a particular group, click the post message button. You’re done with your first one! Congratulations? THAT’S IT!! All you have to do is jump to different newsgroups and post away, after you get the hang of it, it will take about 30 seconds for each newsgroup!


$$ JUST MAKE SURE THE EMAIL YOU SUPPY IS EXACTLY AS IT APPEARS ON PAYPAL. $$ Now the WHY part: Out of 200 postings, say I receive only 5 replies (a very low example). So then I Made $5.00 with my name at #6 on the letter. Now, each of the 5 persons who just sent me $1.00 make the MINIMUM 200 postings, each with my name at #5 and only 5 persons respond to each of the original 5, that is another $25.00 for me, now those 25 each make 200 MINIMUM posts with my name at #4 and only 5 replies each, I will bring in an additional $125.00! Now, those 125 persons turn around and post the MINIMUM 200 with my name at #3 and only receive 5 replies each, I will make an additional $625.00! OK, now here is the fun part, each of those 625 persons post a MINIMUM 200 letters with my name at #2 and they only receive 5 replies that just made me $3,125.00!!! Those 3,125 persons will all deliver this message to 200 newsgroups with my name at #1 and if still 5 persons per 200 newsgroups react I will receive $15,625.00! With an original investment of only $6.00!

A – M – A – Z – I – N – G – $$

$$ When your name is no longer on the list, you just take latest posting in the newsgroups, and send out another $6.00 to names on the list, putting your name at number 6 again. And start posting again. The thing to remember is, do you realize that thousands of people all over the world are joining the internet and reading these articles everyday, JUST LIKE YOU are now!! So can you afford $6?? And see if it really works?? I think so? People have said, what if the plan is played out and no one sends you the money? So what are the chances of that happening when there are tons of new honest users and new honest people who are joining the internet and newsgroups everyday and are willing to give it a try? Estimates are at 20,000 to 50,000 new users, every day, with thousands of those joining the actual Internet.

Remember, play FAIRLY and HONESTLY and this will work. Seriously, most people think this is a scam, but you actually do get thousands of dollars out of it, it is NOT another crazy stupid scam, if people follow through with sending out $6, it works!!!!!


Look at what PayPal had to say about it! (or ask them for yourself)

Dear ************

Thank you for contacting PayPal. We apologize for the delay in responding to your service request.

It has come to our attention that there is a PayPal scheme floating around at the moment you may have heard or seen the $5 scheme. You may have even taken part in it well we have been asked a lot of questions about this scheme the answer is yes it does work and yes it is safe to use providing you follow the rules it is legal and has made a big hit on the internet this year.

Thank you for using PayPal! Sincerely, PayPal Community Support.

There’s no use trying to cheat for only $6.00 ***

$$ Have fun! $$

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: