Tyler to Will:
No you can’t agree with me because its absurd. I can agree with your absurd view, but you can’t agree with mine.
That is from my Bloggingheads debut; Robin Hanson reproduces one critical and entertaining part of the transcript, in which I explain which is my most absurd belief.
Here is the link to the show, I am sorry that I cannot embed it. The chat covers many topics, including whether capitalism will triumph, whether you should have more kids, and which country is most likely to be hit by the next nuclear weapon attack. Can you guess my pick? Hint: It’s not the U.S. or even Saudi Arabia or Israel.
I conclude with this:
If no one agrees with you, you should be quite worried. If only a small number of people agree with you, you still should be quite worried. I don’t think it’s a numbers game, but I think whatever view you end up with, it doesn’t have to be a majority point of view, that reasons have weight, not just adding up whoever agrees with you. But you still ought to say at the end of the day, look all those other people are against me, maybe I think I’m right probability 57 to 43, but on any truly controversial question among intelligent people, you should never think it’s 95 to 5 in your favor.
Addendum: Ann Althouse embeds the parenting discussion.