“Free Markets Foster Competition”

That's a chapter title from Jonathan Franzen's new book Freedom.  If you think you are going to like this book, you almost certainly will; it delivers on its promise.  The problem is, I never thought I was going to like this book.

This passage is one of many that made me cringe:

"And while you're here hon, can you help me with my taxes?  They're due tomorrow and my nails are wet." 

Is there any surer way to long for Victor Hugo and "men as they ought to be"?

I almost stopped reading it at about p.100.  I was not afraid it would get worse, rather I was afraid it would get better and I would start liking it and finish it.

Which is precisely what is happening.

Comments

Well... *That* chapter in The Corrections almost made me give up reading.

Comments for this post are closed

Never even heard of him, that's why I come here.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Franzen#The_Corrections
Soon afterward, Franzen's invitation to appear on Oprah's show was rescinded. Winfrey announced, "Jonathan Franzen will not be on the Oprah Winfrey show because he is seemingly uncomfortable and conflicted about being chosen as a book club selection. It is never my intention to make anyone uncomfortable or cause anyone conflict. We have decided to skip the dinner and we're moving on to the next book."

I wonder if Oprah gets her irony. If not, here goes. Oprah, you were offended because you do think your attention is a kind of gift. You do think you affect readership and you obviously do. You did. It's why you do it. He said so. It's why you were offended. Why writers have this strange relationship with commercialism I don't know, but artistes don't listen to me, thank God. Why not produce a men's show?

Comments for this post are closed

I'm just trying to figure out when the secret vote was taken that decided Franzen was the greatest writer of his generation.

Comments for this post are closed

Tyler, have you read Warlock by Oakley Hall? It's full of ideas about law, legitimacy, and justice, plus "men as they ought to be" wondering how precisely they ought to be.

Comments for this post are closed

I clicked on the comments link only to discover that "Eli" above wrote the exact sentence I wanted to write:

"Weirdest book review ever."

Comments for this post are closed

Mind telling why you cringed? Why you disliked the first 100 pages? What youliked about the rest? And why in heaven's name would you want to not like a book, and why you would keep reading it while wanting not to like it? Right now this isn't a book review, this is kinda of the prologue to a review.

Comments for this post are closed

The quote deserves context-- It's a quip delivered in icy irritation by a character, and captures both her jealousy/resentment and lack of respect for the one who's nails are supposedly "wet." It's not the narrative voice, but rather, the inflected tone of that character. I rate the Corrections as the best book of the noughties. As but one tiny validation of his magisterial intellect, the book in 2001 described a music startup called "eigen-Melody", and at that very moment startups in SF were using those very statistical techniques to develop a music preference engine. Last night, I heard Jonathan Franzen launch his book tour at the Capitola Book Cafe (just south of Santa Cruz, and apparently a good enough place for birding to draw Franzen away from NY for part of every year). My major question (being about 200 pp into Freedom): Is it plausible that the lengthy embedded autobiography could be such a virtuosic work (it's written by the very same woman whose mouth spoke Tyler's arch quote).

Comments for this post are closed

I think he is saying that he didnt want to love a book by such a popular writer. Franzen gets a lot of press, to the extent that you can find his novels in your local grocery store.

Comments for this post are closed

Maybe Tyler just reads so many books that sometimes he wants a book to be bad so that he can skip to the next one. If he wanted every book to be good, if he wanted to like everything, then he would end up finishing too many books. Or maybe he fears that if he starts liking a relatively unimportant book, he will have to finish it, leaving him less time for more important ones.

Comments for this post are closed

If I had a nickel for every time someone threatened to stop reading Tyler Cowen...

Comments for this post are closed

Comments for this post are closed