Here is my response to Brian Doherty’s CatoUnbound essay, and here is opening bit:
Brian Doherty asks: "Did this libertarian movement . . . actually accomplish anything of unquestionable significance?"
Yes: Bigger government.
Or try this:
The old formulas were “big government was bad” and “liberty is
good,” but these are not exactly equal in their implications. The
second motto – “liberty is good” – is the more important. And the older
story of “big government crushes liberty” is being superseded by
“advances in liberty bring bigger government.”
aren’t used to reacting to that second story, because it goes against
the “liberty vs. power” paradigm burned into our brains. That’s why
libertarianism is in an intellectual crisis today.