If Ezra Klein were Tyler Cowen

A very good post.  On the specifics: relative to most libertarian economists, I am more likely to think — or should I say admit — that human beings are irrational, even when the stakes are high (see the self-deception chapter in Discover Your Inner Economist).  But, relative to social democrats, I tend to think that politicians are irrational actors trying to pander to irrational voters and that it can’t be any other way.  I am much less optimistic about democracy as an instrument for fine-tuning good policy or for that matter as a medium for enforcing progressive sentiments.  On health care I don’t think the solution is to strip away insurance, a’la HSAs, so I agree with Ezra’s paragraph more than not.  On The Wire, the defect is fully mine.  I’ve watched seven or eight episodes, from seasons one and three, and I thought: this is fantastic.  But I never really looked forward to the next episode and eventually I stopped watching.  I have an inability to appreciate all things gritty, regardless of medium.  I don’t enjoy Grapes of Wrath either, or for that matter Goodfellas.  I wonder if needing a tinge of romanticism isn’t some kind of character weakness of mine.

Addendum: Kevin Drum comments on the last round.

Comments

I'll add this and Mr. Klein should consider this when yapping about economic issues:

Relative to Ezra Klein and other Social Democrats, Tyler Cowen is far more likely to make sense and be on the right side of an economic policy matter.

Comments for this post are closed

"Tyler Cowen is far more likely to make sense and be on the right side of an economic policy matter."

Yay for romanticism! There's a revealing truth in this commenter's quote...

Not that I mind.

Emphasis on the dysfunction inherent in the political process, has Tyler ever worked for a private firm? I have, small, medium, and very large, and in government labs, and excelled at all. Galbraith Sr. was not wrong... the smartest people in the bomb labs are just as smart as the smartest people at google.

Now if you could just extinguish some of those government functions that live too long. Like NASA, for instance. But not NOAA.

This is the problem with government. I wish to believe that it is solvable. After listening to several MLK speeches on KFJC tonight, I think it possible.

Comments for this post are closed

"I wonder if needing a tinge of romanticism isn't some kind of character weakness of mine."

Have you read, and did you really dislike Annie Proulx's "Wyoming Tales"? That book still depresses me when I think about it!

Comments for this post are closed

Further bravo to Tyler for engaging with these folks.

Rationally, we are more likely to achieve "peace" by talking to eachother.

But at this point, after struggling to gird myself so that I can protect my family and my voluntary associations and institutions, as well as make a positive contribution to socieity, I pretty much resent someone telling me how I have to do even more to protect someone I would choose not to, because it's better for the "whole."

I'm more likely to tell them "Go fund yourself."

Comments for this post are closed

Klein says:

"But it is, at base, a disagreement over the likely behavior of humans, and how we should respond to it. The Cato employees of the world -- Tyler is not one, incidentally -- simply have a much more optimistic take on the individual's mastery over his sphere. We are, with a bit of an assist from price signals, doctors, stockbrokers, bond traders, pension planners, and much else. I on the other hand, see more in the way of frailty and shortcomings, and am instead deeply optimistic that our self-knowledge of those vulnerabilities allow us to stand together and protect each other against not only the vicissitudes of a dangerous world, but occasionally, against ourselves."

No, no, no! The alternatives are not either:

A) Be your own doctor, stock-broker, bond-trader, and pension planner, or

B) Have a social democratic government decide to handle all those decisions and provide all those services for you (whether you like it or not).

I am not my own doctor. But nor am I my own plumber or auto-mechanic. Yes, people often benefit from expert advice and assistance. But, no, people don't need the government to tell them when they must seek it out. And they *really* don't need the government to impose itself as the monopolistic supplier expertise and assistance.

Comments for this post are closed

I understand the craving for romanticism, but I'm still able to love The Wire and Goodfellas because I try to focus on the question, "How good is this TV show/movie at accomplishing what it set out to do?" To me, they both excel.

Comments for this post are closed

In his Nobel prize lecture (http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economics/laureates/2002/kahnemann-lecture.pdf) Kahneman talks about two modes of thought - System 1 (intuition) and System 2 (rationality) - to explain how errors in judgement occur and how we correct for those errors. System 1 intuition is fast, parallel, automatic, effortless and associative, while System 2 reasoning is slow, serial, controlled, effortful, and rule governed. Further, System 1 intuition is slow-learning, while System 2 reasoning is flexible.

Perhaps society as a whole is like an individual trying to cope with uncertainty relying on System 1 and System 2 like processes. We need both System 1 (individual decision-making) and System 2 (collective decision-making).

Comments for this post are closed

I wonder if there's a relationship between interest in / tolerance for "gritty" narratives and the political viewpoints of an audience; might narrative grittiness add a human face to certain negative externalities of the free market?

Comments for this post are closed

Very nice article! Thanks for this!

Comments for this post are closed

Well, I've read 'em both, and I think Tyler Cowen makes a better Ezra Klein than Ezra Klein does--certainly a more politically sophisticated one. Obama would, as Cowen notes, be much better positioned to get something substantive done than Clinton--and that matters more than the details of your campaign planks.

Comments for this post are closed

Comments for this post are closed