David Wallace-Wells on the pandemic

Rather than quote the parts where he says nice things about Alex and me, how about a wee excerpt on the GBD crowd:

Dr. Bhattacharya, for instance, proclaimed in The Wall Street Journal in March 2020 that Covid-19 was only one-tenth as deadly as the flu. In January 2021 he wrote an opinion essay for the Indian publication The Print suggesting that the majority of the country had acquired natural immunity from infection already and warning that a mass vaccination program would do more harm than good for people already infected. Shortly thereafter, the country’s brutal Delta wave killed perhaps several million Indians. In May 2020, Dr. Gupta suggested that the virus might kill around five in 10,000 people it infected, when the true figure in a naïve population was about one in 100 or 200, and that Covid was “on its way out” in Britain. At that point, it had killed about 45,000 Britons, and it would go on to kill about 170,000 more. The following year, Dr. Bhattacharya and Dr. Kulldorff together made the same point about the disease in the United States — that the pandemic was “on its way out” — on a day when the American death toll was approaching 600,000. Today it is 1.1 million and growing.

It has fallen down the memory hole a bit just how um…”off” these people were, and that is the polite word.  That said, I don’t think they should have been banned from any social media platforms.  Here is the full NYT piece, excellent throughout, and mostly about other topics.  For the pointer I thank Alex T.