Pittsburgh facts of the day

I’ve always had a good time in Pittsburgh, and it’s a visually striking city in a way that I think impresses visitors. Pittsburgh has also normally had a lower homicide rate than the other important city in Pennsylvania and comparable “rust belt” cities like Cleveland and Detroit.

That generates good vibes and tends to give it a kind of broadly positive reputation. But I’m always a little bit puzzled by the notion of Pittsburgh as an urban turnaround success story. Pittsburgh had 676,806 residents in the 1950 Census. That fell steadily in the second half of the 20th century to just 334,563 residents by the 2000 Census. And then in the 21st century, while the reinvention was supposedly happening, the population just kept falling at a slower pace, and in the 2021 estimate, there were only 300,453 people left. It’s true that this is a smaller population loss than Cleveland, Detroit, or St. Louis. But it’s worse than Milwaukee or Baltimore and only very slightly better than Buffalo.

I think the main lesson of Pittsburgh is just that it underscores how severe the headwinds are for central cities that have cold winters.

Those are from Matt Yglesias ($).