Oliver Williamson and the pin factory

In Adam Smith there is the pin factory and the market and from that beginning we trace the long literature in economics focused on the twin questions, What price to set?  How much to produce?  Following Coase, Williamson asks different questions, Why a pin factory?  Why are the 18 steps to make a pin performed by a single firm rather than two or more?  Why are there many firms instead of one large firm?  Why does the pin factory not vertically integrate upwards to buy the steel factory and downwards to buy the retail hardware shop?

Williamson’s answers rest on the notions of bounded rationality, contract incompleteness, asset specificity and opportunism. Start at the end, asset specificity and opportunism.  When a deal has been sealed the parties typically move from having many potential partners to being locked in.  That’s bad because it raises the possibility of opportunism–one party can exploit the other.  But it’s also good because when the lock-in is credible each party may be more willing to invest in assets which are extra-productive but specific to the relationship.

Marriage, for example, takes away some possibilities but it adds others.  With marriage, for example, comes a greater willingness to invest in children (n.b. asset specificity, the child is of extra value but only to the specific parties involved in the marriage) but that very benefit also means that one of the parties has the leverage to be opportunistic.  Knowing all of this when they enter the contract the parties bargain ex-ante, they exchange promises and make investments (the ring), they establish rules for ex-post bargaining or decide on the background rules to apply in that eventually (pre-nup, no fault divorce, covenant marriage).  The rules are never perfect and the contacts are always incomplete.

Transaction cost economics is all about applying these ideas in different settings to figure out the best governance structures (marriage, vertical integration etc.) in different circumstances. How does one deal with expensive investments (such as highly
individual dies or plant construction) that are specific to a given
trade and put the investor at risk yet which increase productivity? Williamson analyzes how firms
come to rely on long term contracts or vertical integration or other
seemingly non-competitive solutions to enhance market productivity.
Early generations of antitrust enforcers often saw these as
monopolistic dealings, but scholars such as Williamson helped us
understand how these are essential to the workings of the invisible
hand.

Williamson’s paper, The Economics of Governance (working version) published in the May 2005 AER is an excellent recent summary of his views in the area.

Williamson’s work is notable for inspiring a large body of empirical and theoretical work in modern industrial organization and having influence in law, political science, and management. His work has been widely cited, and by some counts he was the most widely cited economist in the world.

I especially thank John Nye who contributed to this post.

Comments

Didn't Coase already win a Nobel for this idea? What did Williamson add?

Think you could ask Professor Nye to guestblog on MR for a week?

Were Smith's pins the wee chaps used for cloth, or the small nails used in woodwork?

Do you even think before you post? Marriage adds possibilites? Like children? As if you couldn't have children outside of marriage? Were you born in 1912 or something?

Marriage is a risky social contract whereby people pool their resources to reduce housing costs and increase the chances for health insurance. I like you Tyler, but sometimes you write some really stupid things.

"people pool their resources to reduce housing costs and increase the chances for health insurance"

So why do people get married outside America? Will universal healthcare lead to a surge in co-habitation? In reality marriage allows you to hold your partner to greater account for cheating, hence increases your confidence that the kids are yours.

Relax Benny

In reply to Max on cell phone/carrier exclusivity deals:

The carriers want new, cool devices to attract customers. Once an individual is with a certain carrier, she tends to stay (for at least a while), and if you stick with one carrier, you can get a discounted rate talking to other subscribers. So it's "come for the gadget, stay for the network effects."

The device makers get a marketing boost out of it. The carrier will advertise the device on TV (if it's cool enough), the Internet, and inside their stores.

now I'm wondering about why marriages don't vertically integrate.

You never heard of in-laws?

@Millian:
So why do people get married outside America?

At a far lower rate! Just compare marriage statistics between the U.S. and Europe. Economic benefits change a large part of the picture. And whining about cheating spouses is just loser talk.

@Alex: Why change the wording if you are right all along? When is Tyler coming back?

Benny Lava, Ruman...are you a trainned economists?
Benny, read the whole thing before misquoting.
Ruman, children has nothing to do with assets. Parents expect no return on them. And are willing to carry them as long as they are alive.
I might concede there is a return, but only within spiritual realm.
Besides, no action of your children or yours will diminish their value.
Marriage is a ritual.
And its "market value" rest on social networks expanded by the expansion on personal ID of both persons.

As the time for disciplanary bounds may be opening, people should revisit Alfred Chandler's THE VISIBLE HAND OF MANAGEMENT. Won the Bancroft and Pulitzer. Key in business history.

Maybe someone should write a post on Volokh itself, since the two earlier posts about this year’s Nobel seem to have received very little attention. You’d think lawyers would be more interested in the Economics Nobel Prize going to two people who have been thinking all their lives about

He hella rich for God sake..

The interesting parts to me are section 154.125, which sets a guideline award at a different percent of "net resources" depending on the number of children being supported, and section 154.124, which allows the parents to set the child support by agreement, so long as the court ratifies the agreement as being in the child's best interest.

i really appreciate what you're doing here. very interesting site. Supposed you allday!you have a very talented and skilled writting. i had a great time reading your comments.

thank you! I like this news, I also have information to share, here is my message.zxcv

Vibram five fits like a glove covered hand. Shoes give an idea of how to guarantee a fully naked, with adequate protection in the field of security. Each five fingers are independent, Moscow, like a second skin, a real foot, Augloves Au.They very easy, so fans of his bare feet feel a great vibram shoes freedom.

This is quite interesting to read. A kind of supreme idea! Thanks for all your amazing efforts.

So it requires real identification to go through. Not that I disagree on this, but I think it's nothing new than others.

In the process of game, each pair of supra skytop shoes are a unique individual character, besides the impressive appearance, also noticed that it was special shock system Supra Skytop II shoes will protect your feet. American brand in shoes began to produce functional slide supra skytop, appeared in recent years, as a new force and luxury material and exaggerated form, causing many stars in their representative unconditionally. For men in cheap supra skytops, welcome to our online shop.

Thanks for your sharing.
Simple style and great versatility make Coach Handbag ideal work-and-play bags.Today you can get all the Coach purses at lower price in our store.All the Coach Outlet will actually fix the eyes of passers-by.

I'm glad to see this artical, you can write more just like this style.And I will come back again.

Government are the management company. Government works for us, the people. We, the people, pay tax to fund them in keeping our country clean, tidy, safe, to keep water and electricity running.
iPad screen repair

I'm from France and i think at least some other country should have got it maybe us in France we are in the Congo on peace keeping missions.and the euro has increased in value so we have America beat in both peace and economics.

As the time for disciplanary bounds may be opening, people should revisit Alfred Chandler's THE VISIBLE HAND OF MANAGEMENT. Won the Bancroft and Pulitzer. Key in business history. Hair Extensions London

A hair dryer will work, as will lacquer thinner, but there is going to be a line trace showing because the exposed paint has faded and the paint under the strip has not faded. keep that in mind.

Why don't you try the Big 4 for a summer job? Trial and error will not hurt you, instead you'll gain some experiences and become more determine in what you want to be in the future.

hary
The most popular sneakers online shop. All Juicy Outlet are guaranteed authentic. There are so many great things about this shoe but..it is not very durable! I wore these Chanel Handbag for about 3 monthes and the bottom started to come off:I am getting a new pair because i LOVE them sooo much! Wish they didn't break! Chanel have new arrivals from nike sneakers for girls. Today we present Nike Air Jordan, this air jordans comes in white, pure purple and neon turquoise. These shoes are very lightweight which is great for someone like me. Cheap Jordans are very comfortable on the one foot I do have. The Juicy Couture Handbags locks my foot into place so I know I am less likely to get hurt while playing hard.

Everyone listened, super good news, I think I found a very interesting thing!

Didn't Coase already win a Nobel for this idea? What did Williamson add?
buy cheap software

A hair dryer will work, as will lacquer thinner, but there is going to be a line trace showing because the exposed paint has faded and the paint under the strip has not faded. keep that in mind.
Life Insurance

I agree with this. But I need more information bout this. If I read this page, it’ll make our life easier. life Insurance Australia

He cant keep it as clandestine as he would wish it to be. This still needs some evaluation.

The gap between the riches and poors are really worrying. When too few people are enjoying most of the outstanding money, there must be social issues in the community. Heathrow Airport Parking

Of course another set of evaluation must be sought. One look doesn't really suffice for this.

Helping each other not only in this site. You can help them by teach them to have a skill. Not only giving money.
pool tile cleaning

Many application you can download in this windows. They make many programmes that can attract many people.
ribbon

Looking forward for the next information technology you have. I really think this is incredible.
document management software

Wow! They have a big number in that exercise thing. That’s must be free and open for all community.
Sex

Like this laptop. I hope it have a good battery that last more than six hours.
blackjack games

Maybe he need to play another music genre in every occasion. Surprise us as your fans.
test de paternité

Like this band. I always love music. They make a good one. Its different from other band, theu have a specific sounds that you can recognize everytime you hear their playing. SEO

My boyfriend understand bout this better than me. So I will ask him to explain this to me.
Savings Accounts

I don’t understand much bout this. I open this page coz my froens told me bout this. But I do have interest in this. Maybe if I continue read I will understand this.
Ray Ban Sunglasses

This is a good site if you want to buy a new car with a good budget. They make a good review so you know wthat the best specification for you. Good site to help you to choose the best car.
cheap fish bowls

You can make alink in this page to your twitter. It will make you easier to share this information to all people you know in your social network. Like this post.
Nottingham Photographer

ロレックスコピー,ブランドコピー時計,ロレックス腕時計,ロレックス時計,ブランド腕時計,ロレックス

We must have concern to that immigrants. We must have system and policy in this thing. We cant accept all of them in our country. They must have a good reason why we accept them in our country.
nice meal

I live in Spain, and found this article very interesting

Many people think that you only can put your gps in your car. But that is wrong. You can put your gps everywhere and you can bring it everywhere you like.
electric cigarettes

Thanks for this post.It offers some information .Although i am from China.Thanks for sharing.

http://shopatoutlet.com/
It sales Christian louboutin products at very low price but with good quality.

Many young musicians perfoem in this show. They have a good skill and ability to be a good performer someday. This is a place to find many good musicians. You must use this opputurnity wisely.
cheap airsoft guns

I must admit that our government have the best domestic politic that other country. But they have the worst foreign politics too. They just think bout our country, don’t care bout other country. This is not good.
Scottsdale Real Estate

Obama is try to be better than the president before him. He need time. We need to give him time to let hin show his ability to make america is better than before.
sentricon

She make a lot outfit in every concert. She never wear the same outfit in every concert. For me its more like a fashion show. Make you always want to see what kind of outfit that she wear this time. That outfit is all good.
Lionheart Assurance Solutions LP scam

Every company want to have a very loyal employee. Beside that smart is a must. You cant have a bad employee. This will make your company getting worst from the first time. This is a good post to make sure you know bout that.
Holiday photo cards

I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the comment here!

This is a very popular blog. You can put your advertisement in here. I think many people will see that and you soon have a big business.
Guitar Pro

I agree with the majority of your post. To add my own thoughts I think that peace is very important to society and economics. As they help people prosper.

She have a boyfriend and the media blow up that news. Its interesting to know all that gossip bout celebrity. I like to watch the show bout them. Well that is the concequences to be a star you know. san francisco car accident attorney

I have many merchandise from her. That is why i like to buy her latest album. She always give a good merchandise. In earliar album, we can get a bracelet.isnt that great? Dissertation Editing Services

She looks better than before. More pretty and more sexy. She must go to beauty salloon to make that happen. You can make a change like her to if you got to the beauty saloon. Sälja guld

Every people have their own disease. We have a different way of life and habit. This is why so many disease that happen around us. Everyday there are a new kind of disease. Bad things in our life. House of Pearl

He is graduated from Harveard university in law majoring. This is very good. At least we know that he have a smart brain coz that university is really famous with their alumnus.
Industry Magazines

What sign that you are talking about? You need to write more specific bout that. I know that theres alot of sign that happen in our life. But i think its all allright.
GPS Navigation System

I like this site. It tell me much and really helpful with that tips. We try to make a good relation but it always end up wrong. I dont know what happen. I just dont want to break up like my friend.
Message On Hold

Reading and commenting on blog posts is a great way to share interesting and important information

チューダーは、高級時計のロドニーデンジャーフィールド似ていた過去の時計:彼らは!"まったく敬意を取得していない"チューダーは、残念なことにも名称を抱えている、"貧乏人のロレックス"時計それは残念だ以来、常に1945年にブランドの創業以来、上質、よく練られた時計をされている。その前に、ロレックスは、同社の市場シェアを拡大するマルコーニ、ユニコーン、およびRolcoようになりました忘れて名前を持つ安価な時計の寄せ集めを売却した。

I have my role businessman, he have a lot of business in property and have a high class supermarket for rich people. But he always friendly to all the people he met. He wear a very usual outfit. We never think that he is a succesful businessman until you know his name.
design agency manchester

The good aspect bout this are many young people who wants to be athlete. But the bad thing bout this are they always play this game and forget to study. I always angry to my little brother if he forget his time.
Internet marketing agency

This is a good thing to read even youre not in that position. I like to read all the tips that they hav in here. I think they want to make all people have a good relationship in their life.
Escorts in Las Vegas

They must need a lot of money in the election day. That is why the senior politician help them to raise a fund for them. They can use this in their campaign before the election day.
lingerie store

My friends like to climb the mountain. They always try to climb the highest peak of mountain in this world. I never have guts to do that. I cant stand the cold. I heard a lot of people get hypotermia while do that.
Free Strip Poker

I go to the hollywood last week. I have a good time there and i really enjoy my trip. There are many things that we can visit and do in hollywood. I take a tour that show us the crib of holywood star.
freeze dried acai

War is a bad thing to do. I dont like to have war again. We must live in peace. This veterans thru a difficult time during that war and they like to tell the story of their life. Its always fun to hear their story.
wooden jigsaw puzzles

hello to all I'm new to this site and good day to all,,just wanna say thanks for this post a great help

to me. .I was very pleased to find this site. =)

Thanks for sharing this information it’s always interesting to read other peoples thoughts

I hope in the future we will have that studio too in my country. This is really fantastic. And have a studio for 3D movies such this diet coke. Or maybe the 4D studio. It will be much better.
Jogos Online

Great blog post, thanks for sharing, blog reading and commenting is such a great way to pass the time

We have this system too in my country and this is really make me happy to know that you have this system too. This will save time and money. And i think all countryu in this world should have this system too.
Property Management

This is the worst part that we are facing nowaday. Maybe we already independent but in this, we still have a big problem in this. People live in this situation, its just the same like they're not independent yet.
Herbal Supplements

Our brain supplements
(HCF Happy, Calm & Focused) is all natural, providing essential thinking amino acids and neuro-nutrients which support the nourishment of your brain with key ingredients responsible for helping you feel happy, calm and focused every day.† *

Claim your FREE* HCF 90ct bottle and find out first-hand the difference of amino-acid brain supplementation!

Well, all people have their own thought. If you think bout all that, that will make you crazy. Just do what you have to do and be honest in all you do. That will make you a good politician and sonner or later people will know bout that.
cheap caskets

this thing is worth to read. we enjoy it.

We will start selling iPhone 4 conversion kits here soon,
and they will be available worldwide. But for the time being
check out this place for your White iPhone 4.They sell the kits,
and do the installation. They will continue to be our preferred
installer, even after we start selling the kits ourselves.
We are just working on the very best webstore You will see.

thanks for the post.i realy appreciate your effort..

I want to be a good parent and this is the first place that i can leran to be a good parents. Its not easy to learn, but its always easy if you remember your own kids face at home. House of Pearl

Dean- if you knew anything you'd know Andrew Johns nearly broke his already damaged neck when he got stretchered off, he couldn't move even if he wanted to. Mini could still move, does that add up to you? Idiot.

Maybe I Should someone write a post on Volokh Itself, since the two discussed earlier posts about this year's Nobel Seem To Have Received very little attention. You'd think lawyers Would be more interested in the Economics Nobel Prize going to two people who Have Been thinking about all Their Lives...
orkut

Wow! This is cool. We dont need to go to the dance studio to learn how to dance. We only need to buy the video and start to practice in our own house. I will buy this video for sure.
Organic Wheatgrass Juice Powder

Thanks for sharing all the information, reading and commenting on blog posts is such a great way to learn about things you wouldn’t otherwise know

Last year they make a concert in another town. This year then make in texas. Of course this is will happen every year and they will cjhoose a different town every year.
frankincense and myrrh

She will make another concert after she finished her latest album. This concert from her album before this. They will make a different concert in every country that they visit.
Penny Auction

Thank you for sharing this information. The information was very helpful and saved a lot of my time.

Dissertation Writing

hi im ken. hello to all..
HCF™ Happy, Calm & Focused™ includes the extensively researched 'Essential' (only comes from outside food or supplement) Amino Acid 'F' known as a nutritional precursor to the neurotransmitters Dopamine, Norepinephrine (noradrenaline), Epinephrine (adrenaline) which strongly support warm feelings of love, pleasure, happiness, alertness, energy, motivation, memory, attention, internal calmness, and sleep to name just a few!

Previous comment did not get posted for some reason but I just wanted to say that I was impressed by the comment list here. Shows a great post!

Thanks for sharing all the information in this blog, reading and commenting on blog posts is such a great way of learning

I love art. This make our life more colourful with its beauty. I like painting and the dance that they found many years ago. I also like all the clothes by designer. That is art too, to me.
Gatwick valet parking

I rather take care my own heatlh than to see a doctor. I always eat healthy food and i always think about the sugar that i eat everyday. This is important to make sure that i dont have diabetic disease.
web search

Hello good day to all, ,I'm AnNe new to this site. .A cool site to visit, Boosting Brain Power Now Possible: While Millions Worry About Mental Fitness... . so pleased to find this site . . =)

People that lives in here really friendly. They want to have a good life but they dont know how to have that kind of life. We need to teach them bout that. First of all, we need to make them understand that its important to make your place stay clean.
finance jobs

Hello good day to all, ,I'm Rexiel new to this site. .A cool site to visit, Boosting Brain Power Now Possible: While Millions Worry About Mental Fitness... . so pleased to find this site calm supplement . . =)

Every people have their own wany to appreciate their relationship with other people. All the way that they choose will make all these people have a different relationship with around them.
Silk Bags

Why you named your site like this? People will hard to understand what you have in this site if you don’t make the specisific name in your site. Or you do that in purpose to make evcerybody want to know and at last they make a simple click and end up here.
North Carolina motorcycle accident attorney

Look at their expression. All of them really enjoy their time and they really having fun with their friends. We should make another activity like this again. Its for them.
New Bingo Sites

I take part in several programme that they have, I remember the programme that we have in one country named kiygisthan. I don’t know if that the right spell or not. Nut that is a good country. tantei

Here are special greetings And the best of wishes, too - May Christmas and the coming year Bring happiness to you!

All the people around m,e like this movie. They said that this is the good movie and they think this must ne a good movie of the year.. And I agree with that. They have a good choice like me.
build websites

I Li to find out bout this site. Imagine if you can write your critic and advice that you can write to tell to your own government. Itys important to let them know if you have sometghing in mond.
Calgary Web Design

弊店は時計産業の分野で何年間経営を経って高い評判を勝ち取りました、ブランド腕時計、ブランドコピー時計、ロレックス腕時計、ロレックスコピーなどブランド腕時計を揃って販売します。全ての腕時計は厳格なプロセスを通して製造します。

You need to stay in that country first. I think its more than three month and then they will check the documentation that you have. You need to have a good background, you lnow.
orlando dentist

So many restaurant in this world. This is the real competitors for you that have business in restaurant. But if you have the good taste and the unoque taste, people will always come back to ypur restaurant again and again.
oak wardrobes

Logo design

Interesting post. Thanks for sharing this information.

http://www.logodesignmaestro.com

http://www.asicsusashoes.com/

Outsource Mastery is your perfect business partner in helping you live to your company's full potential
This may mean a lot of changes, a big change for or even little changes that matter so much for your
organization and business in the long run.

So many information that you can find in the internet vbout having and starting a good and healthy life. If you try this, im sure this will keep the doctor away. After all, we work to make money for us, not to give it to the doctor. Free Slots No Download no Registration

You can start to buy the ticket if you want to watch the concert. You need to do that if you don’t want to run out of their ticket concert. I heard that he is the youngest from that trio.
Small business factoring

The short article about the work in modern industrial organization and having influence in law and management was really interesting. Definitely marriage deals with exchange promises and make investments for childrens especially. Mobile App

Applying the concept to ordinary social structures such as corporate business and marriage is an interesting idea. I suppose in many ways these structures only reflect the micro isms of the macro economic society. Online Stock Trading

The pin factory, like the magniwork generator is a fscinating topic, I hope you will agree.

cool style...

Comments for this post are closed