That is the new book by Claire Adida, David Laitin, and Marie-Anne Valfort. Some parts are interesting, especially those showing both statistical and taste-based discrimination against Muslims in France. But most of the book — above all the title — makes claims which are far too strong. A better description would have been “Why France Has Not Integrated Its Muslims.”
To cite one obvious problem, the book only offers four pages of text on Muslim integration in America, a relatively successful venture. And most of those four pages deal with Detroit. The authors’ own evidence just doesn’t seem so damning, for instance when it comes to “Proud to be an American,” on a scale of one to four, Arab Christians come in at 3.67 for the first generation, and 3.75 for the second or third generation. Arab Muslims come in at 3.47 for the first generation, and 3.52 for the second or third generation. Not perfect to be sure, but is that evidence of a massive problem?
There is no talk of Pakistanis in America, a highly successful group with a median income higher than for America as a whole. Nor is there a peep about Bosnian-Americans, who are mostly Muslim and fairly well integrated. How about Iranians, a very successful group in America?
The word “Canada” does not appear in the index of this book.
I could go on. C’mon people, you can do better than this…