Claims about baseball and Palau

Baseball has dominated the cultural and sporting life of Palau for almost 100 years, which is about four times longer than Palau’s been an independent nation. Over the years, Palauans have shaped the game to fit their island lives. Kids learn to play with bamboo bats and coconut-leaf balls. Pitchers chew betel nut instead of dip. Monsoons rain out not just games and series, but entire seasons of league play. Local traditions of witchcraft have crossed over into the country’s sporting life; even today, it’s not uncommon for accusations of black magic to fly after particularly contentious games. (I’ve been reporting on and off from Palau for seven years, so I’m used to it. THIS pitcher’s dad was a known wizard; THAT team’s manager caught women from an opposing village burning leaves over home base.) Baseball as it’s played in Palau is a decidedly Palauan thing.

But baseball has also shaped Palau. It’s more than a national pastime here. It’s an organizing principle—or, more accurately, a re-organizing principle. Before the 20th century, Palau was a matriarchy. Women controlled most aspects of society, and men were limited to fishing, fighting, and handling village-to-village diplomacy. Then colonial rule brought centralized government—and baseball—to the archipelago. Ever since, these two male-dominated worlds have fed on each other, with Palau’s baseball leagues serving as a kind of farm system for government service. Scores of congressmen, senators, diplomats, and heads of state have passed through Palau’s dugouts on their way to political power.

Here is much more, from David Walker, and here is Wikipedia on Palau.  For the pointer I thank Stephen Jonoes.

Comments

Hello, thanks for comments. I am interested in this part of the article: [Before the 20th century, Palau was a matriarchy. Women controlled most aspects of society, and men were limited to fishing, fighting, and handling village-to-village diplomacy.] This seems like a clear contradiction of Marvin Harris's claim (Cows, Pigs, Wars & Witches) that there are no historical matriarchal societies. What do you think of this? Thanks.

I suspect that the point is different definitions of "matriarchy" - for many, if men are in charge of "fighting, and handling village-to-village diplomacy", there is not a matriarchy.

Comments for this post are closed

Comments for this post are closed

Parliament meetings there last three hours. Every ten minutes, someone utters a sentence.

slow clap

Comments for this post are closed

Comments for this post are closed

Another post on sports. I would make a distinction between organized team sports such as baseball and football and individual exercise such as running, biking, or walking. Organized team sports is partly if not mostly about conformity, while individual exercise is the opposite. This being football season, has one ever seen such conformity as a crowd at a football game: individuals "lost" in a crowd. Would fans exhibit such boorish behavior on the their own? To their credit baseball fans are less boorish (if that's a compliment). Then there are the participants. Football is a black man's game watched by white men. Baseball, on the other hand, is a white working class game watched by suburbanites. Get this: a college football team is allowed 85 full scholarships, while a college baseball team is allowed 11.7 full scholarships. Yet, when my Godson was playing competitive youth baseball (so-called "travel" ball), the parents, almost entirely white working class, often expressed that baseball would be their child's ticket to a free college education. The look on their faces when I explained that a college team was allowed only 11.7 full scholarships on a 30-player roster was much like the look on their faces when they hear "fake news". The limitation on scholarships is my explanation why Vanderbilt and UVA can win the college world series. Then why so many black players in the major leagues? They aren't from here, they are from the islands and central America. So how do team sports affect politics here, as baseball affects politics in Palau? Where do youth learn to accept authoritarianism? Not in the library. "At a time when America’s faith in democracy is flagging, the Republicans elected to treat the United States Senate, and the citizens it represents, with all the respect college guys accord public restrooms." Bernie Sanders? No, Will Wilkinson. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/20/opinion/tax-bill-gop-democracy.html

Why is "Godson" capitalized in your prolix missive?

Bonus trivia: "Pitchers chew betel nut instead of dip" - dat be nasty red stuff that Thai grandmas chew. Gives hallucinations.

Comments for this post are closed

So does rayward have whatever Trump has that makes him just babble random bullshit?

Comments for this post are closed

Comments for this post are closed

The greatest baseball player in the universe.

http://www.fullredneck.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/Young-Donald-Trump-6.png

https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-0EA9ctvYHQM/VsJrYDuxA-I/AAAAAAAAvB0/Kkv0_wh4XT0/s1600/trump13x-inset-community.jpg

Reading Roger Angell's "Game Time", short sports story compilation. Surprisingly good and I don't follow baseball.

Bonus trivia: Lenny Dykstra was a cut above all other center fielders in hitting average. Steroids apparently. Amazing what a little science can do.

Comments for this post are closed

Comments for this post are closed

"Before the 20th century, Palau was a matriarchy. Women controlled most aspects of society, and men were limited to fishing, fighting, and handling village-to-village diplomacy."

I admit I know very little about Palau, so maybe I'm wrong, but I know many examples of "this society was a matriarchy" which turned out to be b.s. The "handling village-to-village diplomacy" thing sets off my bs meter. What society entrusts diplomacy to people who otherwise don't have influence over government policy?

A society with less than 25,000 people does. 'Village to village diplomacy' is basically walking over to the next group of 100 people in huts and asking if anyone knows how to repair a boat engine. 'Government policy' is deciding who gets to fish where.

Comments for this post are closed

Comments for this post are closed

fascinating snippet of coevolutionary means and ends and whatnot

Comments for this post are closed

Mc E Mantle forearms.
Nice peaceful night in Cooperstown

Comments for this post are closed

watch me hit caroms off the black seats for fun . . .

Comments for this post are closed

and coast in , with my gimpy knee, for doubles . . .

Comments for this post are closed

a big is here, 4your imagination, yankee stadium -- hammond organ

Comments for this post are closed

bump, bump, bump

Comments for this post are closed

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0rEsVp5tiDQ

Comments for this post are closed

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3rYoRaxgOE0

Comments for this post are closed

"The Pritchetts. The Bluths. The Whites. The Sopranos."

I've only heard of one of those four, and I never watched that show either. Is watching a lot of TV a characteristic of cognitive elites these days?

Probably. So is understanding how to post comments on a blog.

Comments for this post are closed

Comments for this post are closed

I have always wondered why baseball did not put down any roots in the Philippines, given the major American presence of a half century. Baseball caught on in Japan, Korea, and Taiwan with much less American contact.

Comments for this post are closed

Comments for this post are closed