Category: Books
A Chatbot for my Talent book with Daniel Gross
You will find it here, by a GMU undergraduate Momin Kaleem, working out of an incubator. Ask the bot and receive some answers from the book or inspired by the book. How can he make this better for other authors, he wishes to know?
*The Truth Detective*
The author is Tim Harford, illustrated by Ollie Mann, and the subtitle is How to make sense of a world that doesn’t add up. It is described as “for curious kids,” and here is the UK Amazon link.
*Power Failure: The rise and fall of General Electric*
That is the new book by William D. Cohan, which I just reviewed for Times Literary Supplement. Gated, but here is the opening bit:
The individual stocks of the Dow Jones Industrial Average typically fall from grace with some regularity. Of the thirty Dow stocks listed in 1990, for instance, only seven were still in the Dow as of November 2022, mostly because the companies have ceased to be important. Stripped down to its basic fundamentals, that is the tale of General Electric (GE): one of rise and fall. But it had an exceptionally long time at the top. GE has its roots in the 1890s, and by 1993 it was the most valuable company in the United States, with a market value of more than $80 billion. It was removed from the Dow in 2018 – the last original stock from 1896 to leave the index. Its core business had shrunk, with no offsetting growth in another area. Today, the company is no longer a significant object of public attention.
This story can be told in many different ways, and the most impressive feature of William D. Cohan’sPower Failure is that he succeeds with multiple approaches.
You can buy the book here, note the American title is slightly different.
Google Books on steroids?
Google Books on steroids
Search through the contents of 1000s of books!
AI semantic search finds the most relevant passages & GPT writes a summary
Textbooks, classics, histories, science, economics, tech, philosophy – you name it!
Much much more to come 👀
Link below, enjoy! pic.twitter.com/yxqb1R2f90
— Dwarkesh Patel (@dwarkesh_sp) January 17, 2023
Here is the link, I am told I am in there too.
*When the Heavens Went on Sale: The Misfits and Geniuses Racing to Put Space Within Reach*
My Conversation with the excellent Rick Rubin
The Rick Rubin. Here is the transcript and audio, here is part of the summary:
He joined Tyler to discuss how to listen (to music and people), which artistic movement has influenced him most, what Sherlock Holmes taught him about creativity, how streaming is affecting music, whether AI will write good songs, what he likes about satellite radio, why pro wrestling is the most accurate representation of life, why growing up in Long Island was a “miracle,” his ‘do no harm’ approach to working with artist, what makes for a great live album, why Jimi Hendrix owed his success to embracing technology, what made Brian Eno and Brian Wilson great producers, what albums he’s currently producing, and more.
And an excerpt:
COWEN: Do you think the widespread advent of streaming threatens the economic viability of a successful ecosystem for musical production and sale?
RUBIN: I think it can be. I don’t think it is yet. If you look at the history of recorded music, at the time that the Beatles were making albums, I think they were paid several pennies per album sold. Then over time, the artists got more leverage and were able to negotiate better deals. I think it finally culminated in the old music business with Michael Jackson who was getting maybe $2 per album that was sold, which was much more than everybody else. In the early days of singles, people were paid very little. Every time there’s a new format of music, the rights holders seem to take advantage of that.
Like when CDs first came in, artists got paid less on a CD than they did for vinyl, and it’s been very time. Every time there’s a new format, the artist gets paid less. Now, they only get paid less until their attorneys realize, “Oh, in our next deal, we’re going to negotiate to have better digital rights,” or better whatever it is. Then it eventually evens out because ultimately, the artists have a great deal of leverage.
Like now, for the handful of the biggest artists in the world, they probably make more money through streaming music than anyone has ever made in the physical world of music, but it’s very much of a top-down thing. It’s only the very top percent who have that. Eventually, hopefully, it’ll get more equitable. It always has. In every case, it has so I’m optimist that it will again.
COWEN: Do you worry about the decline in music education in American schools? Does that matter for popular music in the future, or do people just teach themselves? There’s YouTube, there’s streaming, whatever.
RUBIN: I don’t think it matters. I like the idea of learning what you want in school. If you want to learn music, it would be nice to have that option, but I think that people learn the things they love wherever they are, not in school.
And this:
RUBIN: Yes. I listen to The Beatles [satellite radio] Channel all the time. I love The Beatles Channel.
COWEN: As do I.
RUBIN: It was funny one of the things that when I was talking to Paul McCartney, one of the first things I said to him was like, “Oh, yes, you make all the music that’s on The Beatles Channel, right? That’s who you are. You’re the guy who makes the music for The Beatles Channel.”
Interesting throughout, and best experienced as a whole. And here is Rick’s new book The Creative Act: The Way of Being.
What I’ve been reading
1. Owen Hopkins, Lost Futures: The Disappearing Architecture of Post-War Britain. Covers the “great” British brutalist buildings of the postwar era, the debates surrounding their demolition, and their eventual demolition. Photos too, excellent to dip into.
2. Anna Grzymala-Busse, Sacred Foundations: The Religious and Medieval Roots of the European State. A good and original book about how European state-building grew out of earlier church traditions. For instance, by the time of the Reformation about half the land in Germany was in the hands of the church. “Church-building” often came first, and then state-building copied and improved on some of the methods.
3. Elizabeth Currid-Halkett, The Overlooked Americans: The Resilience of Our Rural Towns and What it Means for Our Country is a good look at what it promises. Most of all, I like how it stresses that these individuals are more apolitical than often is realized.
4. Judith A. Green, The Normans: Power, Conquest and Culture in 11th Century Europe. The best book on the Normans? And what an opening set of sentences: “In the eleventh century the climate was improving, population was growing, and people were on the move, west from central Asia, and south from north-western Europe. In 1054 the unity of Christianity between east and west was broken, a rift which lasted for centuries. In 1096 the idea of recovering Jerusalem from Muslims was translated into action. Existing empires and principalities were challenged and new polities were founded. War was at the centre of these events, waged by small armies led by men who achieved lasting fame, men such as William the Conqueror, Robert Guiscard, and Bohemond. That these men were of Norman extraction seemed to their chroniclers to be no coincidence.”
And just arrived in my pile is Sandy Baum and Michael McPherson, Campus Economics: How Economic Thinking Can Help Improve College and University Decisions.
I’ve also started (and put down) a bunch of books somewhere between GPT 3.3 and 3.8…and read a bunch of books on Pauline political theology (reading in clusters!), and Jonathan Swift on church-state relations and on religious politics more generally. And yes, Spare is in my reading pile.
Dominant Assurance Contracts for Book Reviews and Blog Posts
Arjun Panickssery at LessWrong is experimenting with dominant assurance contracts as a way to fund the public goods of blog posts and book reviews.
In theory, writers could kickstart posts using dominant assurance contracts. An example (this is a real offer): If you send $20 to arjun.panickssery at Gmail via PayPal by noon New York time on January 21st, I’ll send you back $25 if fewer than 10 people sent me money. If 10 or more people send me money, I’ll post a review of Steven Pinker’s The Sense of Style: The Thinking Person’s Guide to Writing in the 21st Century by the end of the month.
If you think this won’t work you should definitely send him some money.
*The Kural*
Or Tiruvalluvar’s Tirukkural, translated with a preface by Thomas Hitoshi Pruiksma, just published by Beacon Press. This poem, a staple (the staple?) of Tamil literature, is believed to have been composed between the third and fifth centuries AD. The poem covers issues of wisdom, ethics, virtue, wealth, and love. I cannot compare this version to the Tamil original, but it reads nicely and is attractively placed on the page.
Excerpt:
Is she a siren a rare peacock a woman in jewels —
My heart quakes
As if on attack with an army of sirens — the look
She gives when I look
I did not know death but now I do —
Fierce feminine eyes
They don’t fit this young woman — these eyes
That kill those looking
Is it death an eye a deer — her gaze
Contains all three
There should be some extra indentation after each two lines. And does anyone has a link to the whole thing recited in Tamil, I cannot readily find this on YouTube.
My excellent Conversation with Katherine Rundell
One of my favorite CWTs, here is the audio, video, and transcript. Here is part of the summary:
She joined Tyler to discuss how she became obsessed with John Donne, the power of memorizing poetry, the political implications of suicide in the 17th century, the new evidence of Donne’s faith, the contagious intensity of thought in 17th century British life, the effect of the plague on national consciousness, the brutality of boys’ schooling, the thrills and dangers of rooftop walking, why children should be more mischievous, why she’d like to lower the voting age to 16, her favorite UK bookshop, the wonderful weirdness of Diana Wynne Jones, why she has at least one joke about Belgium in every book, what T.S. Eliot missed about John Donne, what it’s like to eat tarantula, the Kafka book she gives to toddlers, why The Book of Common Prayer is underrated, and more.
Here is one excerpt:
COWEN: Now, you have two books, Rooftoppers and Skysteppers, about rooftop walking. Some might call them children’s books. I’m not sure that’s exactly the right description, but what is the greatest danger with rooftop walking?
RUNDELL: Oh, it’s falling off.
COWEN: What leads you to fall off? If you’re rooftop walking, if you were to fall off, what would be the proximate cause of that event?
RUNDELL: Philippe Petit, who is, of course, one of the great roof walkers of the world and the man who strung the wire between the Twin Towers in 1977, talks about vertigo as a beast that has to be tamed piece by piece, that can never be overcome all at once.
Vertigo, he says, is not the fear that you will fall. It is the fear that you will jump. That, of course, is the thing that, when you are roof walking, you are taming. You are trying to unmoor your sense of danger and of not being able to trust yourself not to jump from your sense of beauty and the vision of a city that you get up high.
I roof-walk for very practical reasons: to see views that would otherwise be not really available to me in an increasingly privatized City of London.
And:
COWEN: For you, what is most interesting in Donne’s sermons?
RUNDELL: The thing I find most interesting would be the radical honesty that he has — that you will find in so few other sermons of the time — about the difficulty of finding God. He is a man who writes often with certainty about the idea of reaching the infinite, the divine. But he also writes this famous passage where he says, “I summon God and my angels, and when God and the angels are there, I neglect them for . . .” I forget what it is. “The sound of a carriage, a straw under my knee, a thought, a chimera, and nothing and everything.”
That sense that, even though he had a brain that could control incredibly rigorous poetry, he did not have a brain that would control itself in prayer. He offered that to his congregation as a vulnerability and a piece of honesty that so few sermoners of the time — who thought of themselves more as a regulatory ideal that should never admit vulnerability — would offer.
Definitely recommended. And Katherine’s recent book Super-Infinite: The Transformations of John Donne was perhaps my favorite book of last year.
ChatGPT and the revenge of history
I have been posing it many questions about Jonathan Swift, Adam Smith, and the Bible. Chat does very well in all those areas, and rarely hallucinates. Is it because those are settled, well-established texts, with none of the drama “still in action”?
I suspect Chat is a boon for the historian and the historian of ideas. You can ask Chat about obscure Swift pamphlets and it knows more about them than Google does, or Wikipedia does, by a long mile. Presumably it “reads” them for you?
When I ask about current economists or public intellectuals, however, more errors creep in. Hallucinations become common rather than rare. The most common hallucination I find is that Chat invents co-authorships and conference co-sponsorships like crazy. If you ask it about two living people, and whether they have worked together, the fantasy life version will be rather active, maybe fifty percent of the time?
Presumably that bug will be fixed, but still it seems that for the time being Chat has shifted some real intellectual heft back in antiquarian directions. Perhaps it is harder for statistical estimation to predict words about events that are still going on?
Here are some tips for using ChatGPT.
Of course Chat is already a part of my regular research and learning routine. Woe be unto those who cannot or do not use it effectively! I feel sorry for them, get with the program people…
My reading program for the half-year to come
To be clear, I very much like Lex Fridman’s proposed reading list, and I hope to reread many of those books. Most of them are much deeper than their sometimes reputations, I might add. (For all the stupid whining about the list, odd that no one is asking why he doesn’t read more in Russian.)
If you are curious, here is what I have planned for the first half of the year to come:
1. Review copies that come my way — considerable numbers of them are great! And thank you all for sending.
2. Reading or rereading through the works of Jonathan Swift, for a paper I am writing. The topic is Swift on state-church relations, and as relates to some points from Rene Girard, and Swift on science, as it relates to Peter Thiel.
3. The history of American comedy and stand-up, as relates to a future CWT with Noam Dworman.
4. What is recommended to me by credible others, throughout the course of the year.
5. Many books in Indian history, for the 1600-1800 period, give or take, to prep for a likely CWT with William Dalrymple.
6. Reread and re-study of the New Testament, for CWTs with Tom Holland and David Bentley Hart. And for its own sake too.
7. More British and Irish history, from all eras. That will mean reading in clusters, rather than obsessing over particular volumes. Lately I’ve been reading about British cultural and architectural heritage issues, in part to get a different and more advanced bead on YIMBY-NIMBY conflicts, and also to relearn British history through the history of its major buildings.
8. Haldor Laxness and Jon Fosse are among the classic novels in my queue, neither would be a reread. And I will start the new Javier Marías that comes out in English, it takes me too long in Spanish. Twentieth century Polish poetry, and more on the Polish history of ideas and literature. And I’ve vowed to read more museum catalogs (more picture books!). In German I will try Goethe’s Dichtung und Wahrheit, reread some Rilke, some Tuschel, and maybe some more Herta Müller.
9. Other stuff too, most of all what I buy spontaneously. Just yesterday Deepti Kapoor’s Age of Vice arrived at the house. There is some Eugene Volodazkin on the way.
10. I’ve been reading a good deal lately about neural nets, transformers, and other AI-related topics, but not understanding it very well. YouTube videos have helped only a little. We’ll see if I ramp up those efforts or discard them. I am learning a lot from playing around with GPT, however, and maybe I’ll ask it what else I should read.
Kindle sale for *Talent*
$2.99, buy here, not sure how long that price is good for. I thank Tom Jackson for the pointer.
Top MR Posts of 2022
Here are the top MR posts by views from 2022. Biggest post was Tyler’s
1. Classical liberalism vs. The New Right
followed up by two posts by me on Biden’s student loan plan
2. The Student Loan Giveaway is Much Bigger Than You Think
3. Taxing Mechanical Engineers and Subsidizing Drama Majors
and further posts by me on FTX and the probability of a nuclear war.
5. What is the Probability of a Nuclear War, Redux
I said ProPublica was putting their reputation on the line with the lab-leak report but nevertheless I was too credulous. Much of the factual reporting remains correct, however. Lab leak is very much in play.
6. A “Safety Emergency” Happened at the Wuhan Institute of Virology in November of 2019
Tyler comes in next with a post on criticizing other people in private.
7. How much should you criticize other people?
and two posts on the Russian-Ukraine conflict.
9. How did the IR community get Russia/Ukraine so wrong?
Finally Tyler offers some advice:
Rounding out the top were Best Books of 2022, What Caused the 2020 Spike in Murders and How to Elect Republicans.
What were your favorite MR posts of 2022. What should we revisit?
That was then, this is now
Barnes & Noble has a plan to open 30 stores in 2023, making the bookseller the leader in what’s being called a big-box revival. This expansion comes after more than a decade of shrinking its numbers in response to competition from Amazon. There are even a couple of the new stores being opened in the Boston area that are, perhaps fittingly, going to be in locations previously occupied by Amazon Books.
Here is the full story.
