AIs vs. humans in economics papers
Is agentic research any good? Dr Yanagizawa-Drott and his colleague, Olaf Willner, used an AI verifier to check 1,000 APE papers. None was error-free; 842 contained at least one severe error, including ones invalidating headline results. To see roughly how Ape
stacks up against human primates, The Economist teamed up with Refine, the research-verification firm founded by Dr Golub. Refine chose 100 papers at random from those accepted for publication in the top five journals (including QJE and JPE ) in the first nine months of 2026. It then subjected them to thorough review using several frontier AI models plus a once-over for serious errors by a human reviewer. The exercise flagged 4,158 issues in the 100 papers. One in ten papers contained at least one grave error (other problems concerned interpretation or inconsistencies between tables and text).The two exercises are not directly comparable, but human economists’ lower error rate might give them some hope. In ideas, too, people retain the edge. One experiment, by Alexis Akira Toda of Emory University, found that when considering papers on economic theory alone, AI lowers the cost of checking for a candidate flaw but “does not yet reliably substitute for the human judgment that locates the flaw in the first place”. Another, which compared APE papers with published papers found the difference is mostly in ideas, not execution. In a further study, Michele Zampa of the Geneva Graduate Institute used an AI referee to grade 981 AI papers and 41 human ones on things like the novelty of research questions and acknowledgment of methodological limitations. AI did better in crowded fields with lots of existing research to digest. Humans performed at the same level regardless of the size of the literature.
…Benjamin Kohler of ETH Zürich, another Swiss university, and colleagues, let AI reproduce 48 social-science papers, using only the studies’ raw data and a description of the method. The discrepancies between the original papers and the AI versions were due in roughly equal measure to problems with the AI and human work. But the better the AI model, the more the balance tilted against humans.
Here is more from The Economist, interesting throughout.
Thursday assorted links
1. How to turn AI-written maths into a video.
2. Honeypot markets in everything?
3. Traveling a lot without going on planes (WSJ).
4. American audiovisual exports have plunged in terms of global share (I think that is fine and arguably good, by the way).
5. “There’s been a 30 year debate between cyber revolutionaries and cyber skeptics about how much cyber alone can actually achieve in terms of espionage, sabotage, and destabilisation. The war in Ukraine has swung the empirical pendulum hard toward the skeptics: cyber has played a fairly minimal strategic role, struggling to translate digital disruption into durable physical or political control.” Link, with some more on AI. On AI scenarios, here are some more critical points.
6. Casey Handmer looks at astrophysics research.
8. Kevin Roose on early Anthropic.
9. Nicholas Decker.
10. The utter wisdom of Thomas Nagel. And more. And Erik Hoel. The take from Ben Gross is perhaps the best yet.
The Anthropic IPO
In general I am bullish on the commercial prospects of AI companies, including Anthropic (do note I am on the Advisory Board, though with zero governance role and zero access to internal information).
But I view today’s IPO as a sign of bearishness on any kind of extreme superintelligence, no matter what involved parties might say.
If superintelligence is coming soon, why turn yourself into a public company, with all the extra scrutiny and regulation that requires? Raising extra money through debt is the obvious alternative — why cut other in on such an amazing deal?
Furthermore, true superintelligence is likely to raise real interest rates, which raises the return to borrowing today (you can always reinvest at higher rates later, if you do not need the money for compute, etc.).
Now raising money through debt would be relatively costly for Anthropic, but at the very least they could have shrunk the size of the IPO and borrowed more at the margin. Claude says they would have had to pay about ten to eleven percent on that debt. Alternately, they could just take on Jane Street, Citadel, and others and try to earn money through direct commercial activities (but in fact they cannot, note that).
So presumably Anthropic thinks that pending advances, whatever you might wish to call them, will not with any great certainty yield ten to eleven percent at the margin. That is a perfectly fine view for them to hold, but you all should use the implied inference to calm down a bit about what is coming.
I myself am taking that wise and prudent financial decision under advisement, and it does not imply an incredibly radical near future. Keep in mind that the average return on American corporate capital is about seven percent.
Addendum: Maybe there is some clever 3-D chess strategy whereby they do the IPO, and then turn around and borrow lots at a much lower rate, say six to seven percent. And still come out ahead, relative to no IPO, by busting through a credit constraint. Maybe. We’ll see if that happens, but it strikes me as a rather strained possibility.
Here is some sanity from Theo.
Will Baird, book maven (from my email)
Tyler and Alex,
I have built Marginalia Library: using AI and the archives you have helpfully posted, I found every time a book has been mentioned on Marginal Revolution and created a searchable, browsable catalog.
The catalog currently covers 13,315 mentions of 7,968 books across 7,306 posts. Mentions come from the entire Marginal Revolution corpus, not just posts in the Books category. The site does not directly quote anything from Marginal Revolution other than post titles, which link to the relevant post where a book was mentioned.
In addition to compiling mentioned books, I had Claude determine whether books were evaluated (positively, negatively, or mixed), recommended, or described as “self-recommending.” This let me identify books you’ve both evaluated: while there are 98 books you have evaluated similarly, there are 10 where you’ve differed.
This project was created almost entirely with Claude Code and the Claude API, though I used GPT-6 Luna to do the first pass over the entire archive. I checked about 2,000 links and 650 labels by hand. I’m sure there are still some mistakes, and each record has a contact address for users to reach out with a correction.
I’ve been a reader of Marginal Revolution for a long time and have discovered some of my favorite books by reading about them on MR. This project was a way for me to improve my discovery of new books and learn more about how to use AI (I’m already reading Robert Hughes’ The Fatal Shore after finding it in this process). This is a labor of love: Marginalia Library does not and will not have ads, tracking, or affiliate links, and I plan to keep it current from the weekly Marginal Revolution AI Archive updates.
UK productivity update
Output per hour worked increased by 2.5% in Quarter 3 (July to Sept) 2026 compared with the same quarter a year ago, reflecting a 2.0% increase in GVA and a 0.5% decrease in hours worked.
Output per worker increased by 2.0% in Quarter 3 2026 compared with the same quarter a year ago. This was its strongest growth since Quarter 1 (Jan to Mar) 2018, excluding the pandemic period.
Here is the official release, via Peter Whittaker. First, they are going to squeak through. Second, immigration did not ruin the country and will not lead to civil war.
The economics of investment expensing
In July 2025, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act made 100% equipment expensing permanent after two decades of temporary bonus depreciation. I evaluate this reform in a general-equilibrium heterogeneous-firm model with collateral constraints and nonrefundable tax deductions. When matched to U.S. tax-return and Compustat moments, the model yields three findings. First, permanent expensing raises long-run capital by 4.5% and output and real wages by 1.1%, roughly double the gains without financial frictions. Per present-value dollar of forgone corporate tax revenue, expensing builds 5.6 times as much capital as a tax rate cut, versus 3.4 times without financial frictions. Second, first-year capital purchases are U-shaped in firm age: young constrained firms and mature profitable firms expand, whereas unconstrained middle-aged firms whose investment exceeds taxable income delay purchases. Third, making expensing permanent gives up countercyclical bonus depreciation; enacted at the onset of a recession, a two-year bonus offsets 44% of the five-year investment drop.
Here is the paper by Doruk Gökalp, who is on the job market this year from NYU.
Wednesday assorted links
1. Chinese AI companies way down in value.
2. Allison Schrager is starting a podcast with Ken Rogoff.
3. Extensive survey of students on AI.
5. New version of Claude Blattman.
6. Seb Krier on the Christiano interview. The whole dialogue over this interview is a good example of why we have needed (and not really received) a peer-reviewed tier to the discourse on these aspects of AI safety. A more rigorous argument really needed to be forced here.
Was Achilles Conscious?
Homer’s Greeks had no inner life. That’s the title of a recent introduction to Julian Jaynes’s bicameral theory of mind. To recap: in The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind, Jaynes argued that intelligent behavior preceded introspective consciousness. People could speak, learn, farm, build cities, and solve problems without mentally representing themselves as an “I” deliberating within an internal world.
In Jaynes’s theory, routine behavior followed habit but difficult or unfamiliar situations triggered “command hallucinations,” voices experienced as gods, ancestors, or rulers giving instructions. One part of the mind issued commands; another obeyed—hence “bicameral.” Increasing complexity, migration, and the breakdown of established authority undermined the bicameral mind. Starting around 1200 BC, roughly between the Iliad and the Odyssey, people increasingly began imagining alternatives and narrating their own actions within an internal mental space, in short, they became conscious. Consciousness was thus not a biological given but a product of cultural and linguistic evolution.
I used to dismiss Jaynes’s theory completely, The idea of otherwise normal but unconscious human beings seemed absurd. Today, I am not so sure. If you think AIs are not conscious, then a central premise of Jaynes’s theory becomes much more plausible: namely, a civilization of thinking, talking doing, but unconscious beings. The AIs are an existence proof. That said, I still find the evidence for a sharp break around the Homeric era weak. Linguistic differences between the Iliad and later texts are a weak reed for such a big claim and can be explained in other ways. The case for a near-universal transition in a few centuries is thin. On Occam’s-razor grounds I favor continuity. The fact that some animals appear conscious pushes in the same direction.
AIs also undermine Jaynes’s theory in one way. Jaynes bases part of his theory on a change in the way people spoke—moving from describing their actions in terms of following commands to describing their actions in terms of deliberation and “I.” But if AIs are not conscious, then non-conscious beings can describe what they are doing in conscious terms. Of course, AIs have human culture as a foundation, which the early non-conscious humans would not have had, so I don’t think this is a strong hit on the theory.
Still, Jaynes’s theory is that until very recently most humans lacked introspective consciousness. Does this mean that they couldn’t suffer or didn’t deserve moral consideration? I would think not, but it raises the question of what kind of consciousness are we looking for in AIs? Are AIs as conscious as Jaynes’s Achilles? If we can debate whether Homeric era humans were conscious, it’s no surprise that we have difficulty deciding whether AIs are or could be conscious.
In What Did We Learn from Torturing Babies I wrote about the era when doubts about babies’ capacity to feel pain helped justify surgery without anesthesia. Babies certainly behaved as if they felt pain, but a theory overrode the plain observations. That seems crazy if you take behavior seriously as evidence of experience—a broad Turing-test approach. But taking that approach seriously also suggests AIs might well be conscious.
Ultimately, the issue is not whether Jaynes was right or wrong but the fact that there is any debate at all is telling. We don’t have a good test for consciousness whether applied to the past, to other animals, or to machines. If we are unsure whether Achilles had an inner life perhaps we should be unsure whether Claude has an inner life.
Me on the cyberattacks
Tyler Cowen: Don’t Be Fooled By Randomness
The problems are serious, but the sky is not falling in. When it comes to the recent service outages, keep a few points in mind.
First, cyber risk is considerably higher than it used to be. Due to progress in AI systems, cyber offense has outraced cyber defense. Plenty of experts are attesting that a wide variety of systems can be hacked using advanced AI agents.
Second, not every reported incident is a cyberattack. In many cases we do not know, or somebody knows (one way or the other) and is not telling us. One possibility is that these are normal service outages but the world is paying more attention, so the number of problems appears to be spiraling out of control. Another is that institutions are patching or upgrading their systems to limit future cyberattacks, and something in the upgrade goes wrong, causing an outage.
For instance, Microsoft’s November 12 outage, the FAA’s November 13 ground stop, and JPMorgan Chase’s November 16 outage all seem to have been something other than direct cyberattacks.
Do not be too ready to look for patterns in the data, and recall the title of Nassim Taleb’s book: Fooled by Randomness.
Third, the risk of a larger and costlier AI-driven cyberattack remains real. The United States has redundancy and protective systems built into its national security establishment, its financial institutions, and its basic infrastructure. But those protections are imperfect, and with enough attempts somebody might break through and cause real damage.
We do need an emergency national emphasis on cyber defense, but in the meantime do not get carried away by anecdotes. Scrolling social media is not the best way to process this information. Instead, keep in mind that cybersecurity has been a big problem for a long time.
That is from a broader Free Press symposium.
The Kalshi market on U.S. productivity growth
It is coming in at 2.2%, people. That is for over the next five years.
tys…though even I think it will be a bit higher than that. Yes the liquidity is tiny, but that is endogenous to the reality that huge profits are not to be made there. You are free to trade yourself of course.
What should I ask Alexander Mikaberidze?
He is the author and the new and excellent The Louisiana Purchase: The Grand Bargain and the Making of America. He also wrote The Napoleonic Wars: A Global History, one of my favorite history books. He has extensive other writings on the history of the Russian military during that same period.
Alexander Mikaberidze (Georgian: ალექსანდრე მიქაბერიძე; born 27 January 1978) is a Georgian lawyer, author and historian who specializes in Napoleonic studies. He is a full professor of history and social sciences at Louisiana State University in Shreveport, where he holds the Ruth Herring Noel Endowed Chair for the Curatorship of the James Smith Noel Collection, one of the largest private collections of antiquarian books, prints, and maps in the United States. In 2025, he was granted the Boyd Professorship, the highest and most prestigious academic rank awarded by Louisiana State University.
He is a scholar and historian in the very best old-fashioned sense of the term, one of the most underrated writers and scholars today. So what should I ask him?
Alex Imas and I podcast on the economics of AI
Tuesday assorted links
1. Luka has become a very good player. Defense is much better too.
2. No comment.
3. Did England bribe Scotland into political union?
4. Survey article on the economics of mental health, one of the most important and understudied areas.
5. Science isn’t just a series of lucky accidents.
6. Kalshi five-year productivity growth contract. Go trade!
Adlerlicht, reporting on crime in Germany
In both German and English. Built with AI agents, we are going to see much more of this kind of effort. English-language explainer is here.
The economics of Jensen Huang
Most of my assessment is very positive, but I will excerpt this bit from my latest Free Press piece:
Finally, the company was not built to withstand Huang’s departure. Too much authority and knowledge were concentrated in his hands, as evidenced by his practice of having about 60 different people reporting directly to him. Whatever you may think of that system as a day-to-day routine, it can turn disastrous when the person at the top leaves. No one else has collected and interpreted the information those 60 subordinates have imparted to the CEO. We will see how his interim successor Colette Kress does, but there is a great danger that a lot of the contextual understanding of the company and business departed with Huang.
Again, all those direct reports may have worked wonderfully when things were going great, but as a more general practice it is not resilient. Another way to put the point is that the very best CEOs make themselves at least partially dispensable, rather than indispensable. So a large share price decline, following Huang’s resignation, is a sign of his failures as well as his successes. As one set of commentators wrote recently: “the company was never built for him not to be there.”
And one of the very best Ben Thompson columns (gated!) is on Huang and Nvidia.