Assorted links
1. Rural Mayans on the "trolley problem."
2. Arnold Kling on the Johnson and Kwak book (send me a review copy!). And here is Arnold on liberals and libertarians.
3. Markets in everything and here the Gnome-be-Gone.
Are economics students happier? One estimation from Germany
Michael Tamada sent me notice of a recent study, by Justus Haucap and Ulrich Heimeshoff:
A pair of German economists note that while scholars in their field have vigorously begun analyzing the economics of happiness, no one has studied the happiness of economists themselves. Not till now, anyhow.
Justus Haucap, of Heinrich Heine University of Düsseldorf, and Ulrich Heimeshoff, of the University of Bochum, surveyed 918 students of economics and other social sciences in 2005, then estimated how studying each of the different fields affected individual life satisfaction. They reported their results in a paper titled, "The Happiness of Economists: Estimating the Causal Effect of Studying Economics on Subjective Well-Being."
The news is good – for economics students, anyhow. Applying "innovative instrumental variable methods developed in labor and conflict economics," the researchers identified a positive relationship between the study of economics and individual well-being.
That's German students they surveyed, not American students. The researchers also report that self-described political conservatives (in the German sense) report lower levels of happiness.
They do control for career prospects but if you go to p.9 I do not understand why they chose the instrumental variables they did. The paper itself is here.
The Mystery of Sudden Acceleration
Here is Ted Frank on the Toyota sudden acceleration problem.
The Los Angeles Times recently did a story detailing all of the NHTSA reports of Toyota “sudden acceleration” fatalities, and, though the Times did not mention it, the ages of the drivers involved were striking.
In the 24 cases where driver age was reported or readily inferred, the drivers included those of the ages 60, 61, 63, 66, 68, 71, 72, 72, 77, 79, 83, 85, 89–and I’m leaving out the son whose age wasn’t identified, but whose 94-year-old father died as a passenger.
These “electronic defects” apparently discriminate against the elderly, just as the sudden acceleration of Audis and GM autos did before them.
Statistical Addendum: A number of commentators are worried about selection effects (hat tip Don). Here is background information from FARS. In 2008 there were 50,186 drivers involved in a car accident with a
fatality. Of these 8066 were 60 years of age or over. Thus in 2008 the
probability that a driver in a car accident with a fatality was 60
years of age or over was 16%. Using the figures above the probability
that a driver in a car accident involving sudden acceleration in a Toyota was about
54%. Of course, the sample size is very small.
Facts and figures about Greece
Simon Johnson serves up a grim but realistic report:
…Every 1 percentage point rise in interest rates means Greece needs to send an additional 1.2 percent of GDP abroad to those bondholders.
What if Greek interest rates rise to, say, 10% – a modest premium for a country which has the highest external public debt/GDP ratio in the world, which continues (under the so-called “austerity” program) to refinance even the interest on that debt without actually paying a centime out of its own pocket, and which is struggling to establish any sustained backing from the rest of Europe? Greece would need to send a total of 12% of GDP abroad per year, once they rollover the existing stock of debt to these new rates (nearly half of Greek debt will roll over within 3 years).
This is simply impossible and unheard of for any long period of history. German reparation payments were 2.4 percent of GNP during 1925-32, and in the years immediately after 1982, the net transfer of resources from Latin America was 3.5 percent of GDP (a fifth of its export earnings). Neither of these were good experiences.
On top of all this Greece’s debt, even under the IMF’s mild assumptions, is on a non-convergent path even with the perceived “austerity” measures. Bubble math is easy. Hide all the names and just look at the numbers. If debt looks like it will explode as a percent of GDP, then a spectacular collapse is in the cards.
Addendum: Paul Krugman comments.
Henry Farrell on a European Monetary Fund
The IMF usually has maximal bargaining power at a country’s moment of crisis – it typically cares far less about whether the country makes it through than the country itself does, and hence can extract harsh conditions in return for aid. But – as we have seen with the Greek crisis – EU member states are far less able to simulate indifference when one of their own is in real trouble, both because member states are clubby, involved in iterated bargains etc, and because any real crisis is likely to be highly contagious (especially within the eurozone). In other words, the bargaining power of other EU member states (and of any purported EMF) is quite limited. If Greece really starts going down the tubes, Germany faces the unpalatable choice of either helping out or abandoning the system that it, more than any other member state, created. In short – any EMF, unlike the IMF, needs (a) to concentrate on preventing countries getting into trouble rather than dealing with them when they are already in trouble, and (b) deal with the fact that any country in trouble likely has significant clout in the architecture overseeing it.
Important sentences
Most U.S. citizens, for example, probably don't realize that their country exports as much to Latin America as to the entire European Union.
The full article is here.
Lexington, Kentucky bleg
Where should Alex and I eat there? Lives hang in the balance. Your assistance is much appreciated.
What I’ve been listening to
Norwegian rocker Ida Maria and her debut album, Fortress Round My Heart. Here is one excellent, manic track.
Assorted links
1. Markets in everything: politically incorrect chess sets, such as "Chasidim vs. Franciscans."
2. Google, World Development Indicators.
4. George Selgin on central banks.
Update on Austro-Chinese business cycle theory
Here is David Ignatius:
My favorite analyst of bubble economies is David M. Smick, who predicted the U.S. financial mess in his book "The World Is Curved." He notes some worrying statistics: Until the global financial crisis, Chinese exports represented 43 percent of its gross domestic product. To make up for collapsing foreign demand once the recession hit in 2009, China launched a $1.8 trillion stimulus and lending program — amounting to about 38 percent of its GDP. This money was supposed to reach consumers, but Smick estimates that 85 percent of the subsidized loans went to state-run companies and banks — pumping the investment bubble even larger.
Here is from the FT:
Prices of commercial and residential property in China’s 70 largest cities rose by 10.7 per cent in February from the same period a year earlier, a marked increase from the 9.5 per cent year-on-year gain in January, according to China’s statistics bureau.
I believe that in a time when the U.S. fiscal stimulus is under political fire, many American economists have been reluctant to criticize the Chinese program and send a potentially mixed message.
On a separate but related note, here is a piece on forthcoming rural migration in China.
If you could know only one statistic about an alien civilization
Adam asks:
If you were offered a true statistic about an alien civilization, but only one, what would it be?
How about the real rate of return on capital? The risk premium? The percentage of the population which dies in war each year? Those are what come to mind right away. What else? Ideally you might want a cognitive measure, but their performance on human IQ tests probably would not be useful information. How about "what percentage of our knowledge of mathematics do they also have?" Furthermore, I would not assume they "look like the aliens you see on TV" and would consider a biological statistic (which one?) which expressed what kind of life forms they would count as.
What would you choose?
Markets in everything, eight unconventional ways to be buried
My favorite is number seven:
Pencils made from the carbon of human cremains. 240 pencils can be made from an average body of ash – a lifetime supply of pencils for those left behind.
Each pencil is foil stamped with the name of the person. Only one pencil can be removed at a time, it is then sharpened back into the box causing the sharpenings to occupy the space of the used pencils. Over time the pencil box fills with sharpenings – a new ash, transforming it into an urn. The window acts as a timeline, showing you the amount of pencils left as time goes by.
Nowhere at the link do they say it's for sale, but do you think they are giving it away? I doubt it.
The other seven ways to be buried you will find here. For the pointer I thank Bob Cottrell of The Browser.
Why do people ask questions at public events?
Ian Leslie, a loyal MR reader, asks a perceptive question:
Does anybody have a theory about the length of questions during the Q&A sessions that follow lectures/talks? Is there a relationship between length of question and age, gender, status, place in queue? Why do some people make rambling statements disguised as "questions"? How can moderators avoid such abuse of the process (pleas to keep questions short don't seem to have any effect)?
I see a few uses for public questions:
1. The "make a public statement and show them" motive.
2. The "somehow feel a need to void" motive.
3. The "signal intelligence" motive.
The "really want to know" motive is not absent altogether but I doubt if it is primary.
Anecdotally, I have found that men wearing suspenders are most likely to ask longish, rambling questions.
I am not sure moderators wish to avoid "abuse" of the question and answer process. Perhaps the process is part of what draws people to the talk.
It matters a great deal if people have to write out questions in advance, or during the talk, and a moderator then reads out the question. That mechanism improves question quality and cuts down on the first three motives cited. Yet it is rarely used. In part we wish to experience the contrast between the speaker and the erratic questioners and the resulting drama.
My favorite method for giving "talks" is to offer no formal material but to respond to pre-written questions, which are presented and read off as the "talk" proceeds.
Multiple equilibria Potemkin village economic stimulus of the day
Fake businesses are to be used to lessen the impact of the recession on high streets in North Tyneside.
With 140 empty shops in the borough, council bosses think they have come up with a unique way of ensuring shopping areas remain as vibrant as possible.
The rest of the story is here. For the pointer I thank Bob Cottrell, at The Browser.
Request for requests
It's time that again. What would you like to hear about? Comments are open…