How to understand modern India
I could just rewrite my post How to understand modern China, but change the examples. But you can do that mental exercise yourself, and besides it is easier to access information about India in the English language. So let me try a very specific recommendation for India:
Study Indian textiles and their history
I found this the single most useful way to get a handle on Indian history, a bit less on contemporary India. Here’s why:
1. The artistic side of textile history gives you a clear sense of regional differences, and also Islamic influence, or lack thereof.
2.. It focuses your attention rather immediately on the role of women and women’s work, and also how this interacted with industrialization.
3. In the early 18th century, India was a world leader at cloth production, but it lost this position by the early 19th century. Studying textiles and cloth production offers an excellent window on their major story of economic decline, and how British import penetration, backed by colonialism, contributed to Indian deindustrialization.
4. Relatively poor and neglected regions of India, such as Bihar and Orissa, have a strong presence in Indian folk textile traditions, and you will learn plenty about them.
5. Books on textiles will explain the accompanying information about Indian history in a clearer way than will actual history books about India.
6. People who write books on textiles tend to be both clear and careful I have found, perhaps because they love and collect something delicate.
7. Studying textiles and cloth also brings you right to Gandhi’s “Swadeshi’ movement.
8. Unless your income is really quite modest, you can afford to buy and regularly view some pretty high-quality Indian textiles. In India I’ve found some excellent pieces for as cheap as $200-$250.
9. Studying textiles also will bring to your attention India’s tribes and indigenous peoples. And it ties in readily to India’s broader cultural influence throughout Southeast Asia.
10. Textile books have many pretty pictures.
My favorite books on Indian textiles are cited in my discussion of that topic in Creative Destruction: How Globalization is Changing the World’s Cultures. But it’s more a question of reading a bunch of them, rather than picking out a select few. Simple, direct searches will get you to where you need to go.
My favorite collection of Indian textiles is in the Victoria & Albert museum in London. Sadly, I’ve yet to get to the Calico textiles museum in Ahmedabad, though it is very highly regarded.
Christmas assorted links
1. Google Maps moat.
2. On family estrangements (NYT).
3. Interview with Sujatha Gidla about the reception of her book in India.
4. Elad Blog on Bitcoin network effects.
5. “Among the allegations against UI physics professor Michael Flatté is that he spent more than $8,000 in UI resources on robots “to teach classes, supervise assistants, and attend meetings while he was out of the country or attending conferences.”” Link here.
6. “If only we could find a Sufi master to humble us a bit.“
Merry Christmas!
Andrea Mantegna (Italian (Paduan), about 1431 – 1506)
Adoration of the Magi, 1495 to 1505. From the Getty.
Merry Christmas!
Tis’ the season to be jolly?, or Who needs the child tax credit?
…interest in sex peaks sharply online during major cultural and religious celebrations, regardless of hemisphere location. This online interest, when shifted by nine months, corresponds to documented human births, even after adjusting for numerous factors such as language and amount of free time due to holidays. We further show that mood, measured independently on Twitter, contains distinct collective emotions associated with those cultural celebrations. Our results provide converging evidence that the cyclic sexual and reproductive behavior of human populations is mostly driven by culture and that this interest in sex is associated with specific emotions, characteristic of major cultural and religious celebrations.
That is from Ian B. Wood, et.al., in Nature, via Kevin Lewis. Kevin also refers me to a new paper arguing that “the company” came before and stimulated the development of “the economist.”
Sunday assorted links
Additions to my best books of the year list
Since my longer, full list (and for fiction), more has come out, or I have become aware of some omissions, listed here:
The Valmiki Ramayana, translated by Bibek Debroy. I have only browsed this so far, but it is definitely worthy of mention.
Peter Guardino, Dead March: History of the Mexican-American War. The link brings you to my commentary.
Samanta Schweblin, Fever Dream: A Novel, [Distancia de Rescate].
Navid Kermani, Wonder Beyond Belief: On Christianity. My review is behind the link.
Claire Tomalin, A Life of My Own. Ditto, a real favorite.
Robin Hanson and Kevin Simler, The Elephant in the Brain: Hidden Motives in Everyday Life. At first this was slated for my 2018 list, but it turns out the Kindle edition is out now, so it gets to make both lists.
The New Testament, translated by David Bentley Hart.
Homer, The Odyssey, translated by Emily Wilson. I haven’t read this yet, but it is getting consistently rave reviews.
Karl Sigmund, Exact Thinking in Demented Times. Again, a review is behind the link.
Favorite jazz from 2017
Charles Lloyd New Quartet, Passin’ Thru. If their last few albums were released during the golden age of jazz, they would be revered to this day.
Cecile McLorin Salvant, Dreams and Daggers. The new Ella Fitzgerald.
Alexandre Tharaud, Hommage a’ Barbara, classical pianist goes the route of French song, wonderful acoustics to these arrangements.
Django Bates, Saluting Sgt. Pepper. A German (!) big band redoes the whole album, with a semi-comic music hall feel, intricate horn arrangements, works surprisingly well.
Mulatu of Ethiopia, the title says it all.
Runners-up might be Steve Coleman, Nicole Mitchell, Matt Mitchell, Tyshawn Sorey, Craig Taborn, Rez Abbasi, and Vijay Iyer, but I’m not sure I’ll go back to those in the longer run.
Rabat notes
Is Rabat the nicest city in the Arab world? It sure seems to come close, but as a capital and major recipient of government largesse its recipe probably is not scalable. They are building a new concert hall and also a high-speed rail line up to Tangier. So many vistas are pleasant, the touts are absent, and the food never quite hits Morocco’s peaks, nor is there much in the way of crafts.
The city emits the vibe of not being especially religious. The medina and kasbah are relatively empty of economic activity, having not yet reinvented themselves as yuppie or millennial shopping districts. Other than public works projects, it doesn’t feel as if anything transformative will happen here anytime soon, economically or otherwise. Morocco, of course, did not have an “Arab spring” in 2011, and the monarchy has proven remarkably stable, beyond many people’s expectations. That is perhaps the #1 social science question about Morocco.
The citizens seem to compare themselves more to Spain and France than to say Egypt or Iran; I am not sure that is good for their happiness.
“Nace en Rabat el primer hipopótamo concebido en cautividad en Marruecos.”
The Chellah ruins exhibit traces of Phoenician, Roman, and medieval Arabic pasts, the surrounding landscape design creates a perfect integration. Winter temperatures are in the low to mid 60s. If you have never been to Morocco before, doing the whole flight for a mere two days in Rabat is worth it, but neither is it the country’s leading highlight…
Saturday assorted links
1. Walden has been adapted into a video game.
3. Anti-semitism in Sweden (NYT).
4. Traits that are most similar between spouses.
5. Luigi Zingales is running a new podcast, this one with Kate Waldock.
6. Does a single social science variable explain everything? (speculative)
Are climate and personality related?
To test the relationship between ambient temperature and personality, we conducted two large-scale studies within two geographically large yet culturally distinct countries: China and the United States. Using data from 59 Chinese cities (N = 5,587), machine learning and multilevel analyses revealed that individuals who grew up in areas with milder temperatures (i.e., closer to 22 °C) scored higher on personality factors related to socialization/stability (agreeableness, conscientiousness, emotional stability) and personal growth/plasticity (extraversion, openness to experience). These same relationships between temperature clemency and personality factors were replicated in a larger dataset of 12,499 ZIP-code level locations (the lowest geographic level feasible) within the United States (N = 1,660,638).
That is from Wenqi Wei, et.al., via Kevin Lewis.
How much do colleges boost innovation?
Yes, yes, I know patents are not the right measure, that is what we’ve got:
I exploit historical natural experiments to study how establishing a new college affects local invention. Throughout the nineteenth to the mid-twentieth century, many new colleges were established in the U.S. I use data on the site selection decisions for a subset of these colleges to identify “losing finalist” locations that were strongly considered to become the site of a new college but were ultimately not chosen for reasons that are as good as random assignment. The losing finalists are similar to the winning college counties along observable dimensions. Using the losing finalists as counterfactuals, I find that the establishment of a new college caused 32% more patents per year in college counties relative to the losing finalists. To determine the channels by which colleges increase patenting, I use a novel dataset of college yearbooks and individual-level census data to learn who the additional patents in college counties come from. A college’s alumni account for about 10% of the additional patents, while faculty account for less than 1%. Knowledge spillovers to individuals unaffiliated with the college also account for less than 1% of the additional patents. Migration is the most important channel by which colleges affect local invention, as controlling for county population accounts for 20-40% of the increase in patenting in college counties relative to the losing finalists. The presence of geographic spillovers suggests that colleges do cause an overall net increase in patenting, although I find no evidence that colleges are better at promoting invention than other policies that lead to similar increases in population.
That is from new research by Michael J. Andrews, via the excellent Kevin Lewis.
China-Israel fact of the day
Chinese money is increasingly flowing into Israeli hi-tech companies and is likely to overtake the US as the number one source of foreign investment for the Jewish state.
Here is the full article, via the excellent Mark Thorson.
Friday assorted links
1. Sakunthala’s books of the year.
2. ‘A unique Canadian problem’: Goalie rental apps connect teams with netminders.
3. Deciphering Incan knots. The key work was done by an undergraduate, by the way.
The Running of the Economists!
The annual job market scramble at the AEAs is about to begin. To help you through the madness, Marginal Revolution University, Planet Money and MobLab have teamed up to bring you an overview and guide, featuring Al Roth (on a treadmill), Josh Angrist, Betsey Stevenson and much more!
When you have finished the video you can find tips and links to job market advice at the bottom of this page. Good luck!